Sophia grabbed an album with a green cover, opened it, and immediately started laughing.
"Oh great, you probably found that photo of me wearing nothing but a diaper and rain boots." Bennett rolled his eyes.
Sophia shook her head. "Even better; It's photos of mom and dad!"
"Oh, I wanna see!" Bennett scooted over next to his sister.
Sophia turned the first page and saw a photo of Cassie when she was just a year old. Her blonde hair was in two small pigtails on each side of her head as she sat in her highchair, eating Cheerios on the tray in front of her.
"Man, it's hard to imagine mom ever being that tiny." Bennett laughed as Sophia joined in.
"I know, right? Grandma Sarah said that mom was the smallest when she was born. Ironic now that she towers over Aunt Jessica & Tiffany."
Sophia then turned the page, and they were both greeted with a photo of Aiden as a young boy, wearing a white and blue baseball hat and outfit. His wide grin had a few missing teeth, and he held his bat like he was about to take a baseball pitch.
"Awww, dad looks so cute here." Sophia smiled as she traced the photo with her fingertips.
Bennett cocked his head. "Same goes for dad. He's so short!"
Sophia giggled as she looked down. This photo was of their mother when she was about 7 years old and wearing a pink dress with a frilly skirt over a t-shirt and jeans. She was holding hands with a little boy with brown hair, who was looking up at her. They were both in front of a TV playing Beauty and the Beast.
"Oooooh, that's so CUTE!" Sophia gushed as she took the photo out of its casing to get a closer look.
"I mean, mom does love her Hallmark movies, so I'm not really surprised." Bennett remarked as Sophia flipped the picture over.
"Hey Benny." She pointed at the back of the photo. "Check this out."
Bennett's eyes went to the cursive text written in blue ink. "Aiden & Cassandra. '99"
Sophia nodded her head gently and raised an eyebrow. "I know that mom & dad told us that they knew each other since they were kids, but I didn't know they knew each other THAT long."
She placed the photo back inside the plastic film and turned the page. Her eyes went to a photo of Cassie, which was taken during her senior prom. She was in the front yard of her house; Her blonde hair was done in an immaculate updo, and her sparkling red dress hugged her form, while her date was wearing a matching red vest over his black tuxedo.
"Damn, mom looks hot in this picture!" Sophia said as she looked at the picture with glee.
Bennett studied the photo. "Hey, if mom and dad knew each other from when they were kids, why isn't he her date instead of this rando?"
He gestured to a photo below the one Sophia was looking at, which showed Aiden, wearing plain jeans and a T-shirt, with his arm around Cassie while she was wearing her prom dress. His toothy grin revealed a mouthful of braces.
"Dad's about three years younger than mom. He would've been about 15 years old when this photo was taken. Last I checked, they didn't allow freshmen at the prom." Sophia remarked as she turned the page, and that's when she froze, seemingly out of shock.
"You okay, Soph?" Bennett shook his sister's shoulder with a concerned look on his face.
She shot her head up and turned the book around. Bennett looked at the photo and immediately turned his head away.
"Jesus, Soph, at least warn me next time!" Bennett shouted out as Sophia laughed uncontrollably.
The photo in question had been taken while Aiden and Cassie were on vacation in Hawaii when they were younger. Cassie was wearing an extremely small white bikini; Her outfit barely covered her breasts and vagina, while Aiden was wearing a pair of neon green and blue trunks.
"Oh my god, I can't believe mom used to wear things like that. It's like she's wearing nothing at all." Sophia wiped tears from her eyes as she continued to laugh.
Bennett, however, didn't see the humor in it. "I miss 30 seconds ago when I didn't know that existed."
"I'll bet you wouldn't be complaining if you saw ME wearing it, now would you?" Sophia retorted.
Bennett raised his hand and was about to respond but stopped himself from doing so. His sister had a good point.
That's when Sophia got an idea. She got up and walked to the far end of the room towards some boxes. As she was moving them about, Bennett called out to her.
"Soph, what are you doing?"
Sophia, however, was ignoring him as she rummaged through the boxes, mumbling to herself as she tossed each box to the side. Finally, she saw the box that she had been looking for.
Bennett pressed her once more, "Are you going to say something or...?"
"Found it!" Sophia cried out as she laughed.
"And what exactly did you find?" Her brother asked.
Sophia, with a wide grin on her face, held up the white bikini with her right hand like she was holding a fish by the mouth.
"Oh my god..." Bennett put a hand to his face and shook his head.
"What? You don't want to see me in this?" His sister made a pouty face.
Bennett looked at his sister. "Yes... no... I don't know!"
"C'mon Benny. Your girlfriend thinks she'll look good in this swimsuit. I can toss this on, and we can go for a little swim in the backyard. What do you say?" Sophia grinned at him evilly.
The idea of his sister wearing that tiny bikini was enough to stir his cock ever so slightly... but he did want the final say in the poster Sophia was putting together.
"Okay fine, let's get the photos figured out and then we'll go swimming."
Sophia set the bikini off to the side and sat down next to him. "Okay, Benny, we'll play by your rules... for now." She said with a hint of lust before the two shared a kiss.
Bennett reached into the box and pulled out another photo album. The cover was brown leather and appeared to be fairly worn. "Woah, check this out, Soph."
She took the book from him and opened it up. "Oh wow, these photos look a lot older."
As her eyes scanned the older photographs, one that caught her eye was a black and white photo of a woman standing outside in a 60s style dress holding a baby in her arms. Sophia flipped the photo, and her heart melted.
"Awww, it's Grandma Sarah when she was just a baby!" She smiled as she handed the photo to Bennett.
"Nice find, Soph! Not sure if we'll be able to use it for my poster, but this is crazy. How come we've never seen these photos before?"
Sophia shrugged as she continued to turn some pages before coming across another photo. This one had a reddish hue to it, showing the same woman from before, but sitting in the grass with another baby in her arms, and a little girl with brown hair looking down at it.
"Huh, who's this now...?" As Sophia removed the photo from the book and flipped it, she let out a gasp and dropped the photo as it fluttered to the floor.
Bennett turned his head to her as he was looking at another photo. "What's wrong? You look like you've seen a ghost?"
Sophia could hear her heart beating in her ears as she reached out to the photo with a shaky hand. She looked at the note written in fine cursive on the back:
Sarah, Claire & Barbara.
There was no way...
The words she heard her parents speak came flooding back to her.
"Mmm, cum inside of my ass, little cousin."
"Fuck yeah, I'm going to cum in my cousin-wife's fucking ass!"
"Oh my god... Benny. I think this is a photo of Grandma Sarah and Claire..." Sophia whispered.
Bennett was confused. "Okay? So?"
Sophia flipped the photo towards him. "This is them as kids with their mom!. Don't you get it? Grandma Claire and Sarah are sisters!"
"Maybe it's someone else, like a neighbor of theirs." Benny reasoned with her.
However, Sophia flipped over to the next pages, both showing girls who looked very similar to their grandmothers. Birthday parties, family outings, and school recitals. It was all here.
As they looked through the photos, the look on Bennett's face went from confusion to a cold stare. "Wait... so that means..."
"Mom and dad... they're cousins..." Sophia set the photo down in front of her and let out a deep sigh.
Bennett tried to reach out and grab Sophia's hand to comfort her, but she recoiled her hand away from him like she had been bitten by a snake. Sophia shook her head as she started tearing up.
"I need some time to process all this. Oh god, Benny. You think we're sick or something?" She started bawling her eyes out as she got up.
"Soph, wait!" Bennett reached out to her, but she stepped away from him.
Sophia backed away towards the door. "Please, don't. Our parents, oh god, they're cousins. What if we're attracted to each other because our parents are related?"
Bennett stood up. "That still doesn't change how I feel about you, Soph. Please, can we talk about this?!"
Sophia shook her head and ran out of the room crying. As Bennett stood there, he began to wonder to himself if his sister was right. What if their attraction towards one another was, indeed, hereditary?
As he walked down the stairs to the hallway, he heard the front door open and Aiden call out. "Hey kids, I'm home!"
Bennett made his way to the stairway leading downstairs and greeted his father.
"Hey Dad, how was work?" He said in a monotone voice.
"Busy day, but what can you do?" Aiden said cheerfully. "Where's your sister?"
Bennett looked down the hallway and saw his sister peeking out through the crack in her door before closing it. He turned back to look at Aiden.
"She's in her room. It's been a long day." He told him in a glum voice.
Aiden picked up on this. "Is everything okay, buddy? You seem kind of out of it."
"Yeah, we've been hard at work getting everything ready for the graduation party next week. Sophia found a couple of photos of me for the poster board, and it was brutal moving all those boxes around." Bennett answered.
He noticed Aiden's body tense up upon hearing those words. "Oh... did you now?"
"Yeah, pretty much all of the photos Soph picked out are ones that a bit embarrassing, but I have to admit it'll make a great conversation piece." Bennett forced a smile.
Aiden relaxed upon hearing this. "Well, that's good. I'll get dinner prepped before your mom gets home. She's had a long day getting summer training ready for the volleyball squad.
Bennett nonchalantly nodded his head. "Sounds good, I'll be in my room."
******
No one really spoke at dinner that night. Sophia sat quietly as she ate her food as did Bennett, while Aiden and Cassie spoke about their day. When they asked their kids why they weren't so talkative, Bennett gave them the excuse that they were both tired. Sophia then quickly finished her food and excused herself to her room.
After dinner, Bennett went to his room and lay on his bed. As he looked up at the ceiling, he wrestled with the idea of texting his sister to try and talk to her. However, whenever his sister said that she needed space, she meant it.
"Maybe we were doomed from the start. Maybe she's right." Bennett muttered to no one as he rolled on his side.
He lay on his bed for an hour before he got up, went to his computer, and checked to see if any of his friends were online to play some games. Anything to take his mind off the clusterfuck that had transpired earlier in the day.
Bennett spent the next couple of hours playing the newest Counterstrike game; The sun had now disappeared beyond the horizon as the night sky turned an inky black. He had just logged off to call it a night when he heard a soft knock at his door.
He spun around in his chair and called out. "Come in."
The door opened slowly and there stood his sister. Tears were streaming down her face, and her brown hair looked disheveled. Bennett stood up as she walked in and closed the door behind her.
"Soph? I thought you didn't want to see me." He said to her as she looked at him with her reddened eyes.
Suddenly, she threw herself at him, wrapping her arms around him as she cried onto his shoulder.
"I'm so sorry, Benny! Oh my god, I'm so sorry!" Sophia squeezed him.
Bennett returned her embrace. "It's okay, Soph. I'm not upset. If you feel that way, I won't stop you."
She shook her head and looked up at him. "No, you were right, Benny. As much as I tried to fight it, mom and dad being cousins doesn't change how I feel about you. I love you with all my heart, Benny, and nothing will ever change that."
A smile came across Bennett's face as his heart swelled. "I love you, too, Soph."
The two kissed as Bennett's hands moved to Sophia's ass. She let out a faint moan as she ran her fingers through his hair. After a moment, the two pulled away from each other.
"I would love nothing more than to take you right now, Benny." Sophia smiled at him as she wiped her eyes.
"Yeah, but mom and dad are probably in bed right & about to do butt stuff... probably." Bennett mused, which prompted laughter from Sophia.
"Benny! Oh my god... but I'll never leave your side ever. I promise."
"Me too, Soph. There's no one else I want to be with more than you." Bennett cupped her face with his hand.
Sophia blushed slightly. "I guess we had our first real fight as a couple, so... how about some make-up sex tomorrow when the parents leave?"
"Hmm... and what exactly did you have in mind?" Bennett asked.
Sophia gave him an evil smile. "You'll have to wait and see..."
******
A loud knock came from the door of Bennett's room. He turned over in his bed and called out in a groggy voice.
"Whaisit?"
The door opened and Sophia stepped in wearing nothing but a white cotton bathrobe that came halfway down her thighs.
"Morning, sunshine. Did you sleep well?" She smiled at him as she sashayed towards his bed.
Bennett rubbed his eyes. "Well, I slept a lot better now that you're here."
"Mmm, I'm glad to hear it. So, are you ready for me to make it up to you?" Sophia toyed with the cord, which kept her robe together."
"Of course, it's about time I broke in this bed with a lovely lady." Bennett sat up and took his shirt off.
Sophia, however, shook her head. "Ah ah. Meet me by the pool. You and I are going to have a lot of fun.
She turned on her heel and walked out, leaving Bennett with a sense of anticipation and confusion.
-
Bennett sat on a lounge chair by the pool wearing his black-and-blue swim trunks. The midday sun was already high in the sky, so he decided to work on his tan. He then heard the sliding glass door open and shut.
He glanced over and saw Sophia wearing the same robe she had worn earlier, along with a pair of sunglasses. She shot him a seductive smile as she placed her towel on the chair next to him.
"Care to join me for a dip in the pool, Benny?" Sophia gave him a wide grin.
Before Bennett could respond, Sophia undid the cord to her robe, which then slid off her shoulders to the ground.
"Oh damn!" Bennett exclaimed as he looked at his sister's swimwear, which was the old bikini they had found in the attic the previous day.
The white triangles of cloth did a decent job of covering her nipples and breasts, but the bottoms were a different story. The strings of the bottoms arched over her hip bones and into small patch of cloth which barely covered her pussy and left nothing to the imagination.
"These bottoms were so small that I had to wax down there." She wiggled her hips at Bennett, who eyed her like a hungry wolf.
Sophia turned around and shook her ass at him as she let out a faint giggle. The inverted isosceles triangle started at the cleft of her butt before vanishing in between her buttocks. The outfit alone made Bennett's cock stir to life.
"Do you like it?" Sophia asked him in a cutesy voice.
Bennett stood up and walked towards her. "Like it? You look fucking amazing, Soph!"
"Thanks. Although it's hard to believe that mom used to wear this bikini." Sophia placed her hands on her hips.
"Yeah, but you look so much better in it." He reached out to Sophia, but she playfully batted his hand away.
"Let's cool off first before we heat things up." Sophia turned around and jumped into the pool. As she surfaced, she let out a scream.
Bennett, fearing the worst, jumped in after her and let out a cry as he surfaced. "Holy shit, this water is COLD!"
"I know, that's why I screamed." Sophia laughed as she splashed him with water; Her brown hair clinging to her head and shoulders.
He splashed her back. "I thought you had broken your leg or something."
"Hey, knock it off." Sophia laughed as the two engaged in a splash fight for the next minute.
Eventually, Bennett decided to go in for the kill and tackled Sophia. As her warm, wet body pressed up against his, the two locked eyes and kissed each other passionately.
"God, you look so fucking hot in that bikini." Bennett gasped for air as he broke the kiss.
Sophia kissed him again before speaking. "You want to know where it would look even better? On the ground next to the lounge chair as you fuck my brains out."
With that, she grabbed Bennett's hand, led him out of the pool, and over the lounger closest to the house. As soon as they were next to it, Sophia undid the strings of the bikini, and they fell to the ground. As Bennett kicked his trunks off to the side, his cock now standing at full attention, Sophia crawled onto the lounger and shook her wet ass at him.
"Last time, you fucked a girl on this lounge chair. Now... it's time to fuck a real woman." Sophia said as she looked at him over her shoulder.
Bennett, cock in hand, knelt behind his sister and aimed his dick at her entrance. As soon as he pressed his cockhead against her labia, he slid in effortlessly as the two shared a collective moan.
-
"Fuck me, I can't believe I was this stupid!" Cassie muttered to herself as she parked in the driveway to their home. She had to give a presentation to the CSU athletic board in an hour, and she foolishly left her laptop in her home office..
As she opened the front door, she was greeted with silence. Figuring that her kids were still asleep, she kicked off her black pumps and dashed up the stairs to the home office and grabbed her laptop. Just before she was about to leave the room, she heard a long moan coming from outside.
Fearing that someone might be hurt, she crept to the window to see what was happening. As Cassie looked out the window, her jaw dropped, and her hand went to her mouth.
Down on the lounge chair, Sophia was on her hands and knees, crying out Bennett's name as he fucked her from behind.
"Fuck me, Benny! Oh god, you feel so fucking good!"
Bennett brought his hand up and playfully smacked her ass as he continued thrusting into her. "Take my dick, Soph!"
Cassie took a few steps back from the window, almost tripping over her office chair in the process. Her head was spinning and her body shaking as she tried to comprehend what she had just seen.
"Oh my god..." She began to tear up as she decided to make herself scarce. There was no way she was going to march out there and scream at them. She needed help.
She needed Aiden.
Cassie quietly exited the house, making sure not to make her children aware that she had been watching them. She turned on her car, thanking her lucky stars that she drove an electric vehicle that was as quiet as a mouse and quickly sped off down the street.
******
"Excellent, we look forward to hosting you all next month. Take care, Coach Davison." Aiden smiled as he hung up the phone in his office at the 5280 Volleyball Clinic, which he now ran after taking the reins from its previous owner and founder, Victoria.
As Aiden was about to get up to grab some coffee, a knock came from his door. He looked up and saw Cassie standing there. Her neatly made-up blonde hair was now a mess, and her brown eyes were tear-streaked and red.
"Cass? What are you doing here? Is something wrong?" He stood up and walked over to his wife. Cassie shut the door behind her and immediately embraced Aiden, crying into his shoulder.
"Oh my god, Aiden. It's Sophia & Benny. I don't... I don't know what to do, and I had to cancel the presentation." She sobbed frantically as Aiden rubbed her back.
"Easy now, slow down. Here, why don't you have a seat and let's talk. Are the kids hurt?" Aiden sat her down on the black sofa against the wall of his office before taking a seat next to her.
"The kids aren't hurt, but... Aiden, I don't know if I should even tell you!" Cassie wept as she looked at the floor.
Aiden immediately grabbed her hand and looked at her. "Cass, if this was serious enough for you to cancel a meeting with the board, then it must be important. Just tell me what you saw."
Cassie gently nodded her head and looked at her husband. "I saw them in the backyard... having sex."
"As in... with each other...?" Aiden felt a cold sensation go through him as he uttered those words, knowing full well that's what Cassie had meant.
Cassie nodded her head, sat on the couch with her head down. "They're lovers, Aiden. Oh my god, I can't believe it. Oh my god, did we do this to them?"
Aiden exhaled loudly as he looked up at the ceiling. He recalled the time when their family found out they were lovers. Was it indeed hereditary? Was it their fault?
No...
Aiden shook his head. "As far as I'm concerned, we didn't fail them, but I will say that I didn't have this on my bingo card..."
"Neither did I. What are we going to do, Aiden? I mean, we have to say something!" Cassie calmed down and wiped her eyes.
Aiden rubbed his forehead. "That we do. At the same time... I don't know how to feel. On the one hand, part of me wants to be upset about this. However, there's another part of me that sort of... understands where they're coming from."
"But Aiden, our situation was... is different. At least with us, there's some degree of separation. These are our kids we're talking about here!" Cassie looked over at him and frowned.
Aiden wiped away a tear from her cheek. "Is it really that different? I still vividly remember being scared shitless when I told Gwen and Ana my feelings for you because I was worried about what everyone would think. I can only imagine how frightened Soph and Benny are feeling, hiding this from us."
"But they're brother and sister. They're going to face all sorts of challenges if they go down this route. Do you think they can make it work, baby?" Cassie asked wearily.
Aiden chuckled. "I mean, look at us. We've been married for 21 years and have two amazing children. I can't imagine my life being any better at this point. Still, this is something we need to talk to them about. If they're serious about being together, then they also need to be aware of any obstacles."
"I know, baby." Cassie slumped her head. As much as she didn't want to admit it, she and her husband weren't exactly able to call out their kids for their behavior, but they needed to be prepared for any stigma they might encounter.
******
The house was quiet when Aiden and Cassie returned home. As Aiden called out to the kids to come downstairs, Cassie had made her way outside to the backyard. As she inspected the lounge chair, she saw what appeared to be a small pile of white cloth on the ground next to it.
"What the hell is th-...?" Cassie had bent down to pick up the cloth. She was, however, quick to discover that it wasn't a cloth at all: It was her old bikini from her younger years that Sophia had found.
"Oh, Sophia..." Cassie shook her head and smirked to herself. She picked up the small bikini, rolled it into a ball, and walked inside.
Aiden handed Cassie a bottle of water as she stepped back inside and took notice of what she was carrying.
"What in god's name is that?" Aiden gestured at the cloth in her hand.
Cassie let out a gentle laugh. "Looks like our daughter found my old bikini while they were looking for photos."
Just then, Sophia and Bennett came down the stairs and looked at their parents, who had been waiting for them.
"Hey, mom, how was the presentation?" Sophia asked Cassie, who shook her head and gave a disapproving look.
Aiden cleared his throat and pointed at the dining table. "Why don't you two have a seat right there? We need to talk."
The siblings looked at each other as they felt a sense of dread. As they sat next to each other, Aiden took a seat next to Cassie, who looked between her two kids.
Looking back at Aiden, he gave her an affirming nod before she looked at her kids once more and began to speak.
"So, this morning, I arrived at work for a presentation I was supposed to give to the board of directors. However, I discovered that I had left my laptop at home, so I sped back home to retrieve it from my home office."
Sophia felt a pit in her stomach as she whispered under her breath. "Oh shit..."
Cassie held up her hand. "Let me finish. As I was about to leave, I heard some noises coming from the backyard, so I looked out and I saw you two... having... sex with each other."
The siblings said nothing as they looked at the table, their heads hung in guilt over this revelation.
"So... do you two care to explain to explain to us what's going on?" Aiden finally spoke up.
Bennett looked at Sophia, who looked to be on the verge of tears. Feeling a sense of duty, he cleared his throat and began to speak.
"You saw exactly what you thought you saw. You want the truth? I love Sophia and she loves me." He looked his dad in the eyes.
Aiden exhaled as he rubbed the bridge of his nose. "I understand that, but why?"
"Because he love and cares for me." Sophia finally found the courage to speak up. "Benny might be a goofball, but we've come to the conclusion that we love each other just like you and mom do."
"But honey, he's your brother. Are you sure about this?" Cassie frowned.
Sophia nodded. "More than certain. There's nothing you can say to either of us that will change our minds about this."
"And what about you, Bennett? If you carry this on, this could have a tremendous impact on your hockey career." Aiden said with concern.
Bennett shook his head. "I'm going to do whatever I can to make it work. I would do anything for Soph, and you two both know that."
Cassie and Aiden looked at each other. They knew that there was no way that their children were going to change their minds. With their secret out in the open, they nodded at each other and looked back at the two siblings.
"Well, since you two have your heart set on this, there's something you should know about your father and I." Cassie said as she folded her hands.
"What? That you two are cousins? We found that out yesterday while we were rummaging through the attic." Bennett said nonchalantly.
The room went silent as Cassie put a hand to her mouth, and Aiden leaned back in his chair.
"I guess it was only a matter of time before you two found out, I suppose." Aiden looked at the ground in shame.
"Why the hell didn't you tell us? We're your kids!" Sophia stood up and looked at her mom and dad.
Cassie exhaled and spoke. "We didn't tell you because we didn't want you to think any differently of us. We wanted to tell you, but neither your father nor I could find the correct way to tell you."
"We didn't want to embarrass you or make you feel worthless. So, we just... didn't say anything." Aiden said.
Bennett threw his arms up. "You think that Soph and I would give a shit about that? I mean, yes, it would've come out of left field for us, but that doesn't mean we'd love you two any less."
"Yeah, plus, Bennett and I overheard you two the night that he was supposed to be at his lock-in party. You two are both... very vocal." Sophia added on.
Cassie and Aiden both blushed in unison, confirming their suspicions from earlier.
"Look, we love you both and nothing is ever going to change that. Just no more secrets like that from us, okay?" Bennett said.
Cassie, now wiping a tear from her face, stood up and went over to hug her two kids. Aiden then stood up and joined in.
As they broke apart, Cassie decided to make a remark.
"Just so you know, Sophia. Next time you decide to borrow my old swimwear, please ask for permission first."
The four shared a laugh before heading out for dinner, everyone now free from the burden of the secrets they once carried.
******
Bennett began his freshman year at Boston College as a starting forward on the hockey team. It was very clear to both his coaches and fans that he was an extremely talented player. This became even more apparent when Bennett led the team to victory at the NCAA Frozen Four National Championship.
Incidentally enough, the hardest part of his freshman season was being away from Sophia, who had helped her team at University of Arizona secure the NCAA Volleyball Championship earlier in the school year, much like her mother before her.
The two were immediately the talk of all major news outlets, since it was unprecedented to have two siblings at different colleges excel athletically at the same time.
This success would be repeated the following two years when Boston College and the University of Arizona attained the national titles yet again. Suddenly, the two siblings found themselves on Sports Center, Nationally Syndicated Morning shows and even guest invitations to awards shows.
During her senior year, Sophia was given the chance to try out for the Olympics Team. It was an invitation that she was about to decline since she didn't want to be apart from her brother. Bennett, however, encouraged her to go for it. Two months after she graduated, she helped the USA Volleyball team secure two gold medals at the Madrid Summer Olympics.
Meanwhile, Bennett had grabbed the attention of more than a few NHL scouts, eager to see the young man, who had attained the rank of Captain during his junior year, in the heat of competition. It goes without saying that he was very highly sought after following his fourth consecutive NCAA Title win.
Six months later, he took to the ice as a starting forward for the Las Vegas Golden Knights, who were looking to turn their team around after a notoriously long slump. At the same time, Sophia had begun her second season playing for the Vegas Thrill. Since the siblings were playing professionally in the same town, they both lived in a shared penthouse.
By the end of the season, the volleyball team had secured the national championship, while the Golden Knights, for the first time in nearly 5 years, had a Win-Loss record greater than.500. The following year, The Golden Knights did the unthinkable and somehow secured the Stanley Cup; With Bennett leading the charge.
-
Bennett had just finished talking to the press about his first-ever Stanley Cup, where he, a couple of other players, & the rest of the coaching staff spent half an hour fielding questions from the news media. His body ached from the game and he was looking forward to just going home and going to bed.
As the press conference wrapped up, Bennett walked into the back hallway of the United Center and was greeted by his parents, who had been sitting in the back as they watched him during the press conference.
"Your first Stanley Cup win! Not bad, buddy!" Aiden joked as he embraced his son and patted him on the back.
Cassie then joined the two for a group hug. "We're so proud of you Benny! Oh my god, we can't believe it."
"Heh, neither can I." Bennett took a step back and stretched his arms out. "Ooof, still a bit sore from taking that hit in the 2nd period... where's Soph?"
"She said that she'd meet you back at the hotel room to celebrate." Cassie said with a smile.
Bennett breathed a sigh of relief. His teammates wanted to hit up some nightclub in downtown Chicago to celebrate, complete with VIP treatment, but that didn't interest him. He just wanted to see his sister.
"Good. The guys want to go out and party, but I'm beat. I could use some R & R." Bennett let out a yawn.
Aiden chuckled. "Well, whatever you two end up doing, just be careful. All eyes are literally on you."
"I will, dad." Bennett said with a smile.
-
Bennett slowly opened the door to his hotel room. As he closed it, he noticed a trail of rose petals at his feet, leading from the entryway, through the living area, and into the doorway to the bedroom.
"Soph, are you in here?" He called out.
Her sultry voice called out to him. "In here, baby."
Bennett followed the trail of rose petals until he reached the bedroom; His jaw hitting the floor.
Kneeling on the bed was Sophia, wearing nothing but a smile and a matching black bra and thong. Below her breasts was an elaborate tattoo of feathers with a large dreamcatcher in the center. Matching the dreamcatcher tattoo Bennett had gotten on his chest with her the year prior.
"Well, hello there..." Bennett said as he eyed his sister.
Sophia licked her lips. "And hello to you, my Stanley Cup stud." She patted the side of the bed.
"Why don't you come and join me?"
Bennett quickly disrobed and lay down on the bed next to his sister. She rolled over on top of him and ran her hands down his chest and abs. In the six years they had become lovers, his workout regimen with his college team and the Vegas Knights had benefited his physique in many ways.
The same could be said for Sophia, who now sported a light six-pack thanks to workouts she endured for being a professional volleyball player.
"You looked so good out there tonight, Benny. But I think you look even better like this." Sophia giggled as she wiggled her ass against Bennett's erect cock.
He ran his hands along her sides. "Fuck, I'm so in love with you right now."
Sophia leaned down, and the two locked lips. Bennett's right hand went underneath the back of her thong, where it found her moist slit. He slid a finger inside of her, which caused her to moan loudly.
Sophia broke the kiss and looked down at Bennett. She then stood up and undid the black bra, freeing her perky breasts and the small thong that she wore slid to the floor, revealing her now-bare pussy to him.
Sliding a couple fingers into her pussy, Sophia then withdrew them and placed her fingers into her mouth, making a light moaning noise.
"See how wet I am for you, Benny? I'm so ready to get fucked that big cock of yours. I know you've had a long night, but I think you have what it takes to fill up your sister's cunt with that hot cum of yours."
Those words made Bennett's hard shaft stand at full attention. He stood up and pressed his lips against Sophia's, his cock pressed against her stomach before he looked into her eyes.
"Bend over."
Sophia jumped back on the bed, got on all fours, and wiggled her ass at Bennett. He got behind her and ran the tip of his cock against her slit, causing her to squirm.
"Don't tease me, Benny. Please, fuck me." Sophia pleaded with him softly.
Bennett grabbed onto her ass cheeks, and with a quick buck of his hips, his cock slid into Sophia's wet cunt.
"Oooooooo, yessssss!" Sophia moaned out as Bennett started to fuck her from behind.
"God, you feel so fucking good." Bennett panted as he thrust inside of her.
Sophia looked back at him. "Mmm, so much better than celebrating with the guys, right?"
"You always come first, Soph. This is much better than being at some overpriced... ngh... club." He replied.
"I'll bet none of your teammates have a hot sister they fuck daily, do they?" She teased him further.
Bennett responded by increasing his movements, pummeling her cunt with wanton abandon and she repeatedly cried out his name. The sounds of flesh slapping together echoed throughout the room as Bennett playfully slapped her ass check, prompting a squeal from his sister.
"Ooooh, naughty boy. You love it when I talk to you like that? Mmm, I just love it when my little brother fucks me with that big, hard, dick of his..."
Sophia then moved her legs slightly together and tensed up her abdomen. Suddenly she felt the walls of her pussy grip Bennett's shaft as he slowed his thrusts down.
"Fuck Soph!" Bennett groaned as he looked into her eyes, which had a mischievous look to them.
"I want to milk your cock. I want to feel you explode deep inside of me." Sophia cried out as she squeezed Bennett's cock.
He grabbed onto her sides and thrust deep into her. "Fuck yes, Soph!"
As the two found their rhythm, Sophia looked back at him and said something that made him stop. "By the way, Benny. I'm off the pill now..."
Bennett stopped as he was buried inside of her up to the hilt. "Wha...? Soph?"
"I want you to cum inside of me and knock me up, Benny." Sophia licked her lips at him.
He stared at her as his cock twitched at those words. "Are you... are you sure, Soph?"
"Never been more sure. Besides..." Sophia squeezed her vaginal muscles once more as they constricted around Bennett's dick. "...don't you want to fill my womb up with your cum, Benny? See my belly grow with our child?"
"Soph... you know that people will talk about this. Is this something you really want?" Bennett said as he breathed heavily.
She squeezed her muscles around his shaft again. "More than sure, Benny. Trust me, I've got a plan. Now be a good Stanley Cup stud and knock up your lover."
Those last words echoed through his being as he aggressively thrust into her. Sophia's hair flew all over her head, and the bed began to rock violently. She threw her head back and cried out.
"That's it, Benny. Fuck me! Please cum inside of me!"
Bennett reached over and grabbed both of her breasts, teasing her nipples with his thumb and fingers as he used Sophia's whole body as leverage as he plowed her cunt.
"Cum inside of you... I want to cum inside of you Soph."
Bennett then felt a stirring in his loins as he slowed his thrusts down. Between his fucking and Sophia's pussy on his dick, he knew that he was about to cum.
"Soph. I'm going to cum. Are you... sure you want this?" Bennett asked as he was running out of breath.
She turned her head to look at him. "More than certain, Benny. Fill me up with your love. Your sister. Your lover. Your everything. Give it all to me, Benny."
With one final thrust and a loud groan, Bennett lost all control as he felt his cock shoot off inside of Sophia; The warm essence of love and life flowing into her sacred depths.
Sophia let out a moan as she felt his warm seed fill up her cunt and womb. It felt so right and yet so forbidden.
As Bennett finished, he let go of her. All the aches in his body from the earlier hockey game had finally caught up with him as he withdrew himself from Sophia's pussy and lay down.
Sophia lay down next to him, grabbing a pillow and placing it underneath her hips. She then snuggled next to Bennett, who had placed an arm around her shoulder.
"That was... wow. Soph, you know how to push my buttons but... what's with the pillow?"
Sophia ran a hand along his chest. "It's to keep all your cum inside of me. Something about this felt... I dunno, different?"
"You really want me to knock you up, don't you?" Bennett stroked her hair, and she nodded in affirmation.
"Mmhmm, I've got a plan to make it all work too." Sophia looked into his brown eyes and smiled at him. "We've got a meeting with a... contact tomorrow. Hope you know how to go incognito."
******
"So, what's with all the secrecy, Soph? You're acting like we're on a top-secret mission of sorts." Bennett looked at his sister with suspicion as they stood in the elevator at Caeser's Palace. In order not to draw attention from the press, he had thrown on a baseball cap, sunglasses, and black hoodie.
She smirked at him. "That's because we are. Remember that promise I made to you a couple of years ago about how I'd do anything I can to make the reality of us living as husband and wife a thing? Well, this meeting is, hopefully, going to help us ensure that."
"Please don't tell me you're going to bribe a judge. Our faces are plastered all over ESPN and we don't need a scandal, especially after we won the cup and you with your own championship." Bennett said with a pained look.
"Oh Benny, calm down. It's nothing that evil." Sophia giggled as a long "Boop" sound rang out, indicating they had reached their floor.
The two exited and proceeded down the long, winding hallway until they reached room 785.
"Allow me." Sophia knocked on the door and the two waited. About 15 seconds later, the door opened, and a beautiful woman with jet black hair and blue eyes was there to greet them.
"Well, I'll be damned. Noah was worried that you guys might not even show up at all, with the Stanley Cup win and all" The woman laughed and hugged Sophia first before she embraced Bennett.
"Come in. Come in." The woman with black hair encouraged the siblings to step into their room.
As they walked through the entryway, Bennett noticed a man with wavy black hair sitting at the desk with a laptop, who turned to greet the two.
"Holy shit, I can't believe it! A real-life professional hockey player! Dude, you were amazing on the ice with that breakaway goal during the 3rd period!" The man stood up and shook Bennett's hand.
"Well, thank you...?" Bennett's voice trailed off, and he raised an eyebrow at the man.
"Oh sorry, Benny. This is Noah and Kayla Swenson, they're here on vacation from Portland, Oregon." Sophia introduced the two.
"Well, it's nice to meet you both, but... what's the occasion? Soph was very mum about this meeting." Bennett scratched the back of his neck.
"How much have you told Bennett?" Kayla asked Sophia.
Sophia looked away and shook her head.
Bennett held his hands up. "Sophia didn't tell me much. Also, I'm not much for the swinging lifestyle, so sorry to disappoint anyone in advance."
Sophia reached over and slapped Bennett's arm. "Oh shush, you perv. We're not here to have an orgy. We're here to have a meeting of sorts."
"So, it sounds like you didn't tell him anything? Fine by me. Have a seat and we'll talk shop." Kayla motioned to the sofa, where Bennett and Sophia took a seat, while Noah and Kayla sat on the chairs across from them.
"Can someone tell me what's going on here?" Bennett raised his hand.
Noah cleared his throat. "Yes, so your sister here reached out to us regarding you two being lovers, and we understand where you two are coming from."
Bennett's eyes became wide as he gripped the arm of the sofa with his right hand.
"It's alright, Bennett." Kayla held out her hand. "Like you and Sophia, Noah and I are lovers as well."
"Lovers like us how exactly?" Bennett asked.
Noah cleared his throat. "Kayla and I are brother and sister, just like you."
"I found Noah and Kayla online. They're facing a predicament like our own, and they want to help us." Sophia assured her brother.
Bennett breathed a sigh of relief but was unsure how exactly this couple was going to help. "Help us how exactly? I really hope it doesn't involve anything illegal. Well... more illegal than what all of us have done."
The four started to laugh, releasing some of the tension in the room.
Kayla then made the pitch. "It's quite simple. Noah marries your sister, and I marry Bennett, so we...."
Bennett interrupted her. "Hold up a minute. Sophia is my one and only. Kayla, no offense, you're a beautiful woman and all, but my heart belongs to my sister."
Sophia elbowed him in the side. "Let her finish, Benny."
"Right, so as I was saying..." Kayla resumed. "...we marry each other's sibling, so that way our children carry our names without raising eyebrows."
"I don't follow..." Bennett was concerned.
As Bennett was about to ask another question, Noah further explained the details. "It goes like this: On paper, I'm married to Sophia, and Kayla is married to Bennett. However, that doesn't mean we're going to have children with our legal spouses..."
"That part I get, but wouldn't our kids get each other's last names?" Bennett asked.
Kayla pointed a finger at him. "Yep, and that's the neat thing. When our kids are born, they'll take on the last names of their mother."
Then it clicked for Bennett. "Okay, I'm starting to follow..."
"The plan might seem a bit out there, but Noah and Kayla have put a lot of thought into this, Benny." Sophia put a hand on her brother's shoulder.
Bennett looked at the floor and nodded. "You're right. It's an out-there plan, and it still carries some degree of risk. Plus, Soph and I barely know you two. For all we know, you could be serial killers."
Kayla nodded as Noah reached out and grabbed her hand. "That's right, you don't even know us. We're strangers to you, but we're strangers who understand your situation. If you need some time to think about it, we understand."
"Also, we don't even know how old you two are." Bennett said to Noah & Kayla.
Kayla giggled. "Well, Noah is 30 & I'm 33. I know for a fact that you and Sophia are both 24 & 26. Besides, I've always had a thing for younger men." She finished her statement as she eyed Noah.
Bennett chuckled and leaned back into his seat. "You don't say... Man, I can't believe I'm considering your offer. Can I think about it?"
"Of course. We're in town for another few days. Why don't you think about it and let us know?" Kayla said assuredly as she squeezed Noah's hand.
******
Sophia and Bennett lay in bed together after a wild lovemaking session. As Bennett looked up at the ceiling, he turned his head to the window, which showed off the bright lights of Las Vegas below their shared penthouse. He let out a deep sigh.
"Is something wrong, Benny?" Sophia looked over at him with concern.
Bennett nodded as he rubbed Sophia's slightly rounded stomach. "Yeah, I'm just thinking about Noah & Kayla's offer. I wish it was you and I getting married, but I know that's illegal and stuff. There's a part of me that feels like I'd be betraying you if we went through with this."
"Noah and Kayla feel the same way. They'd rather be marrying each other but I know that's not how it works. It's not just you who's wrestling with this. Am I too you know." Sophia stroked his hair.
Bennett nodded. He hadn't considered that.
Sophia continued. "Look, I know it's not perfect, but this is the best chance we've got at having a family. Besides, it's not like you're going to be crawling into bed with Kayla. You'll just be married to her on paper, as will I with Noah."
"And what will we tell our kids when they ask us one day?" Bennett said worriedly.
Sophia giggled. "We'll tell them the truth when they're old enough. Speaking of, if we go through this plan, I'd like to have Noah & Kayla move in with us. I know them a little better than you and they're good people. They have no one else but each other and, like us, they're also taking a huge risk by doing this."
"Of course they can stay with us. Plus, I think people would get suspicious if we weren't living with our respective spouses." Bennett chuckled as he pulled Sophia in close.
In that moment, their minds were made up.
- Epilogue -
A few months later, the two siblings held a double wedding at the Graceland Chapel, with Bennett marrying Kayla & Sophia marrying Noah; Complete with an Elvis Impersonator officiating. The wedding was subject to media speculation since there were rumors about the nature of their relationship, but it eventually went away.
After she gave birth to twins, a boy and a girl, Sophia would spend three more years playing professionally, including helping the Olympics team secure another Gold Medal in Johannesburg, before returning to Denver to help run the volleyball clinic. Bennett, in turn, was able to be traded to the Colorado Avalanche so he could be at home with Sophia more often.
Officially, Bennett and Kayla's children were named James, Madeline & Henry Swenson., while Noah and Sophia's kids were named Hannah and Brayden Novak-Schroeder. However, the only people who knew the truth of their parentage were the two sets of lovers, their children, along with Aiden and Cassie.