It's quite a sight seeing a powerful man like Carlile go down on his knees and start begging for mercy while making the ugliest face possible.
Tears are escaping from his bloodshot eyes, snot is flowing down from his nose, while he keeps his mouth wide open, continuing with his loud, ugly cry.
Carlile feels wronged because whatever he did to Shiana was before she even met Amon, so he shouldn't be blamed for it now. And that's why this hurts so much.
Feeling the injustice that has fallen upon him makes him angry, sad, scared, and many other intense emotions that go along with his current situation. He has no idea that he is feeling the same emotions that his poor victims felt when he forced them into similar situations.
He made wives and children cry bloody tears by killing their husbands and fathers, bringing great injustice upon them. He made innocent men drown in the depths of their own insanity by putting them in situations that would make anyone's heart ache.
