Gabe
I smacked my flesh stick across Kel's ass causing my dick to lightly become numb as the rear end that it was smacked against it had hardly any fat on it.
I smiled as I guided my missile towards it's second armament deposit and slid my soldier into Kel pop tenting her internal organs as my dick rearranged her insides causing Kel to moan into Summer's mouth as they started kissing.
It wasn't long before my thrusting into Kel's moist confines start to convulse as her body quivered and she leaned forward fast spraying and strong torrent of fluid from her pussy.
It was a good thing we were already in the shower.
I smacked Kel's ass and switched my dick's entry back into Summer and started fucking Summer while Kel calmed down.
I had to play the switch game and suddenly decided to be an ass.
I rubbed Kel's ass, "Do you trust me?"
Kel looked back at me confused, "What are you going to do?"
I repeated my question, "Do you trust me?"
Kel thought about it for a moment before she nodded.
I pulled my stick out of Summer's quivering pussy and instead of guiding it back into Kel's entrance I purposely guided my dick into Kel's rear iris.
Kel instantly screamed, "What the FUCK do you think you're doing????"
I smacked her ass, "Shut up!"
Kel whimpered and muttered, "Yes sir."
I lightly pushed my hardened member on her rear entrance as Kel whined that I was about to take her ass cherry.
I slowly pushed my dick and the head slowly slipped into her ass as Kel moaned, "It's too much."
I spanked her ass, "Pretend I'm inserting your plug and just relax."
Kel whined, "Ok."
Each millimeter I pushed my dick in her the more resistance I got from Kel as she started to whine, "It hurts Gabe please take it out."
I ignored her and continued slowly inserting myself until I got half way as Kel started crying she begged, "Please Gabe it hurts."
I sighed, "Just relax Kel. I promise I won't hurt you."
I stopped pushing my dick into her ass letting Kel get used to having her ass penetrated by something other than her plug.
I slowly pulled myself out until my tip was threatening to exit her asshole.
I lightly spoke, "Remember to relax."
Kel looked back at me with tears in her eyes but nodded.
I slowly pushed myself back in as Kel whimpered as she kept uttering, "It hurts it hurts." Over and over as I stopped myself from going too much deeper.
I slowly withdrew myself from Kel's ass and stopped. Then I slowly pushed back as Kel started to groan but still whimpered.
I continued a nice slow motion being careful to not go too fast nor go too deep.
I focused on Kel making sure I didn't hurt her.
Slowly each new thrust Kel whimpering started to become less and less as her moans started to become more and more frequent until she was getting into it.
Soon Kel was moaning her typical, "Fuck fuck fuck."
She was still whimpering but it was only light.
I lightly stopped and rubbed Kel's back, "You ok?"
Kel panted but could only nod.
I spoke softly, "Want me to keep going?"
Kel hesitated for a moment before she lightly whimpered before she looked at me with teared eyes and gave me a nod.
I nodded and lightly continued fucking Kel's ass this time a little faster and a little faster until I was back at my normal rhythm.
I noticed as I fucked Kel's asshole it was a whole different experience.
Sure Kel has always been tight but her asshole was super tight.
I kept going as I climbed orgasm hill and started just kept my momentum.
Kel begged and pleaded, "Oh fuck oh fuck you're destroying my ass!!!"
Soon she realized that I was getting close due to my grunted and she said something that I never expected, "FUCK MY ASS HARD!!!"
I was done.
I started thrust my entire length as Kel groaned, "Oh fuck!!!!!"
Two things happened at once.
Kel grunted and her body tensed as her usual torrent sprayed out of her pussy against me and I grunted as I blasted my cum deep into Kel's rectum.
Our bodies locked in place as both of us experienced something that neither of us expected each other to do.
Eventually my orgasm subsided and leaned back letting my dick slowly slide out of Kel's ass and she grinned as she felt my dick exited her rear hole.
As soon as my dick left Kel's ass she pretty much collapsed on top of Summer who had just witnessed everything that happened.
I flopped down sitting in the shower and looked at Kel's ass expecting her hole to be bleeding but only found her hole shut back in place my cum sealed inside her rectum.
Kel panted as Summer cooed, "You ok Kelly?"
Kel panted in Summer's shoulder and shakily nodded her head.
I panted and just sat there wondering what caused me to stick my dick in Kel's ass?
Was it because of the party?
Or was it because they had worn their stupid butt plug more than once and I thought it was ok?
I just sat there dumb founded.
*********_***********
Support my hard work! 💪 ✍️
💎30+ Advanced Chapters are currently available in Kofi, make sure to visit and support, while enjoying lots of novels in one place.
ko-fi.com/unluckyguyfr