The scene in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire in which Harry's name comes out of the Goblet when he was not the person who put his name into the Goblet, and Harry already knows the Triwizard Tournament is potentially deadly, and nobody will let Harry refuse to participate, and not one adult speaks up to say, "What the bloody hell are you blighters doing? He's fourteen, so he absolutely shouldn't be in the Tournament. Someone must be plotting to kill him. It doesn't matter what the fourth parchment says, stop acting like fools"—this is the most rage-causing scene of any story I ever have read or ever have seen on screen. The huge unfairness of all the shit Harry catches, hugely galls me!
I have addressed this infuriating scene in two previous stories of mine: "The Boy who Planned" and "Harry Casts a Curse." In this chapter, I return to the well a third time and wallow in the unfairness—at first.
As for the chapter title? A 1980s American television programme, The A-Team, had one character say in every episode, "I love it when a plan comes together." I flipped this recurring line to create the chapter title.
Chapter 3
I Hate it when a Plan DOESN'T Come Together
Twenty-four days later (Monday, 31 October 1994)
5.00pm, the beginning of dinner in the Great Hall
Two hours before the Goblet of Fire drawing
Beauxbatons and Durmstrang arrived at Hogwarts last night
As Albus sat on his golden throne and ate dinner, he thought about what would happen tonight, and about what would happen this year. Albus was about to defeat Tom Riddle by—how ironic—building onto Tom's own evil plot against Harry Potter.
The count of Hogwarts professors (other than Albus himself), Hogwarts students, visiting Beauxbatons professors, visiting Beauxbatons students, visiting Durmstrang professors and visiting Durmstrang students all came to a bit over six hundred magical people tonight.
The deaths of six hundred magicals, most of them children, would be an epic tragedy.
Normally, allowing every one of these six hundred professors and students to die would be unthinkable.
The counterargument: If Tom were allowed to live and to prosper, he would take many more than six hundred lives in the future. Tom would cause a bloodbath amongst Muggles, Muggle-borns, halfbloods, "Blood-Traitor" Purebloods and Death Eater Purebloods.
But if somehow Tom could be stopped today forever, but the cost would be the lives of every wizard and witch (except for Albus) now in the Great Hall, Albus would make the trade. Losing six hundred lives in order to destroy Tom—Albus would make the trade with no hesitation.
Because only Albus understood what the term the Greater Good truly meant. Only Albus did not shy away from the ghastly arithmetic behind this term.
Unfortunately, Albus could not finish Tom today; Albus's cannot-fail plan would take more than a year before Tom was ended forever. But fortunately, the cost of success would not be six hundred wizards and witches. No, the certain, cannot-avoid cost would be the life of only one fourteen-year-old boy—
—a boy who, for some reason that Albus could not guess, now hated Albus ten times worse than did Miss Susan Bones. Which was odd because, after all, it was Miss Bones, not Harry, whom Albus had Confundused.
(Why had Albus Confundused Miss Bones? If the DMLE and the Daily Prophet knew that Albus had problems at Hogwarts, Albus's reputation outside Hogwarts would be lessened and his work would become harder. But for the Greater Good, Albus needed to keep his golden reputation, even if this fine reputation was built on the truth being suppressed.)
In the meantime, Harry might feel hatred towards Albus, but Harry could not escape the fate that Albus was about to lock Harry into. An unfortunate result: The entire student body of three schools would call Harry a liar and a cheater!
Furthermore, when the 24th of November came, Harry would have no good choice except to face a Hungarian Horntail dragon—and if Harry died, the good news was that another of Tom's horcruxes would be destroyed that day.
Which would leave only the finding and the destroying of the remaining horcruxes before Tom could be vanquished forever.
Finding and destroying the Gaunt Ring Horcrux will be tricky, but only I can do it, Albus thought.
As Albus looked over his domain, his gaze fell upon Miss Bones who was sitting at, oddly, the Gryffindor table instead of the Hufflepuff table. Miss Bones was talking with Harry and with other yearmates, and did not notice Albus looking at her.
Dumbledore suspected that when Amelia Bones had taken Miss Susan Bones away from Hogwarts on 3 October, it had been because Albus's Confundus Charm on Miss Bones had been discovered. But maybe not—after all, Dumbledore had not been arrested, anytime in the past four weeks. It remained to be shown whether Miss Bones would not notify her aunt when a Hogwarts emergency happened—such as, say, the Goblet spitting out a fourth name for a three-Champions tournament.
IN-CHAPTER AUTHOR'S NOTE: Albus has no idea why Harry now hates him so much. At first thought, Dumbledore's ignorance makes no sense. In Chapter 1, Amelia Bones recalls that the Hogwarts corridors were "packed with" Listening Charms in 1977; and also, Harry says in the corridors outside the library, just after he learns that Susan Bones was Confundused, "Dumbledore, what you did to Susan was despicable. If something goes bad at school, nobody outside Hogwarts will know we need help."
The fact is, Albus has so many Listening Charms in Hogwarts, he was not listening to the right Listening Charm at the right time.
So Harry's revealing little speech in Chapter 1, Dumbledore never heard it!
Harry's discovery that Dumbledore had mind-whammied Susan Bones to not report emergencies to her Aunt Amelia, why did this enrage Harry towards Dumbledore so much? Because this meant that in the future, when Harry again and again faced deadly danger at Hogwarts, he could hope for no help except from Hogwarts professors, all of whom were obedient to Albus Dumbledore.
END OF IN-CHAPTER AUTHOR'S NOTE
Elsewhere in the Great Hall, still at 5pm
Since this dinner was not an official Hogwarts Feast, Hogwarts students were free to sit with their friends at other tables.
One result of this freedom: The fourth-year part of the Gryffindor table was bulging with bodies during dinner, because Harry had friends now.
Harry was friendly now with all the fourth-year Gryffindors, except for Seamus (who was neither friendly nor unfriendly), and Ron (who insulted Harry, Hermione and Harry's non-Gryffindor friends at every opportunity).
Harry had four Slytherin friends, to Ron's and Draco's disgust: Daphne Greengrass, Tracey Davis, Millicent Bulstrode and Blaise Zabini. All four now were eating at the Gryffindor table.
Harry was friends with all the fourth-year Hufflepuffs except Zacharias Smith, and Harry also was friends with sixth-year Hufflepuff Seeker Cedric Diggory. Susan and the rest of Harry's Hufflepuff friends, except Cedric, now were eating at the Gryffindor table.
As for the Ravenclaws, Harry had three friends amongst the House of Wit: Su Li, Terry Boot and Luna Lovegood. Although truthfully, Terry Boot and Su Li were friendlier with Hermione than with Harry. Harry was unbothered by this fact, and was glad for Hermione. These three Ravenclaws likewise were enjoying Gryffindor hospitality at dinner.
Ravenclaw had created one bit of awkwardness, however. Cho Chang had tried to cut Hermione out of Harry's life and had tried to become Harry's official girlfriend. Hermione had been snippy to Cho until Harry loudly and forcefully had told Cho to get lost, but Ginny had become almost homicidal to Cho.
Two hours later, at 7pm: the Goblet of Fire drawing
Still in the Great Hall
For the Goblet of Fire drawing, every Hogwarts student who had eaten dinner at a table not his own, left it and returned to his own table. Nobody wanted to be seen as disloyal to the House if his or her Housemate was chosen as the Hogwarts Triwizard Tournament Champion.
As a result, Gryffindor table no longer was packed solid.
After the Goblet spit out its first parchment, Harry heard Dumbledore announce that the first Champion was Durmstrang's Viktor Krum, the professional Quidditch Seeker. Harry thought, I'm sure he's Durmstrang's most deserving by far, candidate for Champion.
Harry's response to Viktor's selection was mild; Ron's was anything but. Ron yelled the length of the Great Hall, "YOU GO, VIKTOR KRUM! YOU DESERVE TO WIN!"
The second Champion to be chosen was from Beauxbatons: a stunning, gorgeous blonde named Fleur Delacour.
Hermione remarked, "The Goblet doesn't care about looks. Which means Mlle Delacour must be much more than a pretty face. I look forward to watching her progress."
When Cedric was selected as the Hogwarts Champion, the Hufflepuff students lost all dignity—they were loudly cheering, they were singing, they were waving, and they were dancing in the aisles.
Harry and Hermione, for their part, stood up at the Gryffindor table and applauded Cedric.
This is when the Goblet spit out a fourth parchment.
The Great Hall went silent. Harry saw many shocked faces.
Since Dumbledore acted unsurprised, almost everyone in the Great Hall surely assumed the reason was Dumbledore's unflappability kicking in. However, Harry, Hermione, Susan and Daphne—amongst others—knew better.
Before Dumbledore even read out the name on the parchment, Harry murmured to Hermione, "Now the fun begins."
Headmaster Dumbledore's eyes were twinkling.
Susan Bones, who was sitting on the side of the Hufflepuff table that was facing Harry and Hermione, was smirking. Dumbledore should have worried about Susan's smirk.
At the Slytherin table, Daphne Greengrass likewise was smirking. She knew what was coming.
"HARRY POTTER!" Dumbledore called out, loudly enough that everyone in the Great Hall could hear him clearly.
A ginger-haired Gryffindor yelled at Harry, "WHAT? YOU CHEATER! AFTER YOU SAID YOU WEREN'T ENTERING THR TRIWIZARD, YOU'RE A LIAR TOO!"
Harry rolled his eyes. "Whatever, Ron."
Then Harry stood up, but made no move to step away from his piece of Gryffindor bench. Harry drew his wand and pointed it at the ceiling.
Just as loudly as Dumbledore had spoken and just as clearly, Harry said, "I REFUSE TO BE A CHAMPION. I DID NOT PUT MY NAME INTO THE GOBLET OF FIRE TO BE SELECTED. I DID NOT ASK SOMEONE OF-AGE TO PUT MY NAME IN FOR ME, AND NOBODY OF-AGE INFORMED ME HE OR SHE INTENDED TO PUT MY NAME IN. I SWEAR ALL THIS ON MY MAGIC."
Light flashed. Students gasped.
As Harry restowed his wand, he said, "In short, I am not a Triwizard Tournament Champion."
Dumbledore actually looked sad: "I am so sorry, Harry my boy, but your oath changes nothing. Your name came out of the Goblet, therefore you are a Champion. There is nothing I can do. It is time for you to join the three other Champions in the Entrance Hall."
Harry, "No, I don't accept that. I want other opinions! Mr Crouch, Mr Bagman, Madame Maxime, Headmaster Karkaroff, what say you lot?"
McGonagall yelled, "POTTER! You should trust the headmaster's word! If he says you are a Champion and you need to go to the Entrance Hall, don't dawdle!"
Harry replied, "Oh, I fully trust the headmaster—to figuratively bugger me. He's destroyed my life nonstop since I was fifteen months old. So I'm not surprised that if there is a Tournament that would force me into three deadly spectacles, Albus here wants to sign me up!"
Then Harry looked at the other adults in the room. "You folks I named, what say you?"
Headmaster Karkaroff said that Harry's name coming out of the Goblet was "disgraceful"; Karkaroff blamed Dumbledore for the unexpected parchment. Karkaroff's opinion was that Harry did not need to participate.
Beauxbatons's Madame Maxime said she was "withholding judgement." Dumbledore gave her a puzzled look.
Mr Crouch said that Harry's name came out of the Goblet, thus he had to participate, Q.E.D.
Then in case Harry had not heard Mr Crouch the first time, the bureaucrat repeated his message: "Mr Potter, your name coming out of the Goblet creates a binding magical contract. You must compete."
Ludo Bagman was almost doing cartwheels, he was so overjoyed about Harry being a Triwizard Tournament Champion. So Ludo exercising his authority and declaring that Harry was not a Champion? No chance.
"Harry," Dumbledore said, "it is past time for you to join the other Champions in the Entrance Hall."
But Harry made no effort to move towards the Entrance Hall. Instead, Harry shot a meaningful look towards Susan Bones.
One second later
Susan Bones surprised the entire Great Hall when she stood up at the Hufflepuff table. Then she stuck two fingers inside her shirt collar and said, "Auntie, Harry is the fourth Champion, Harry is fourth, Harry is fourth!"
Seconds later, Harry heard Amelia Bones's contralto voice coming from Susan's shirt collar; but Harry could not make out Amelia's words.
Meanwhile, Dumbledore, as well as Karkaroff and Maxime, were staring at Susan Bones in surprise.
The three headmasters got another surprise, a big one, when a man's hand and a wand appeared, seemingly out of thin air, directly in front of "Mad-Eye" Moody, who was sitting at the High Table. A man's voice said "Stupefy," then a red spell hit "Mad-Eye" in the chest. Mr "Constant Vigilance" did not have time to dodge.
Suddenly Sirius Black stood between the four House tables and the High Table, whilst standing in front of slumped-down "Mad-Eye." Sirius's wand was in his right hand and the True Cloak of Invisibility was in Sirius's left hand.
Sirius smirked at Dumbledore. "Surprised to not see me? Harry's house-elf fixed your dangerous alteration of James' cloak."
Then Sirius turned to face Snape. Sirius stood straight and said formally, "Potions Master Snape, I suspect that the hip flask that 'Mad-Eye' carries, contains Polyjuice Potion. Please prove or disprove my suspicion."
Less than a minute later, Snape had sniffed the hip flask, and had poured a small amount of liquid onto Mad-Eye's golden dinner plate. Snape looked at Sirius and said formally, "I confirm that this flask contains Polyjuice Potion."
Then Snape drew his wand with a dueller's speed and cast Rescindere Polyjuiceum on "Mad-Eye"—
—who turned into a man in his thirties with two good eyes, two good legs, a complete nose, and sand-coloured hair.
"That's Barty Crouch, Jr!" McGonagall blurted. "But he's supposed to be dead!"
Sirius, clearly unsurprised, replied, "Indeed it's he."
Then Sirius hit the unconscious man with the IncarcerousCharm.
Susan again stuck two fingers inside her shirt collar. "Auntie, Mad-Eye's flask has Polyjuice Potion. 'Mad-Eye' isn't 'Mad-Eye,' he's a young man named Barty."
Harry heard Susan's shirt collar reply, "Barty Crouch, Jr? Isn't he dead? Merlin on a mushroom! We're coming, Susan."
Meanwhile, Harry still was standing up at the Gryffindor table, and Dumbledore still was holding the parchment with Harry's name on it—
—though now Dumbledore's attention was entirely on Susan Bones, not on Harry. Dumbledore looked worried.
Dumbledore had not cancelled his demand that Harry join the "other Champions" in the Entrance Hall, though now the odds of Harry agreeing to this demand were a flat zero.
Harry did not move now, but Sirius Black did. He spun round to point his wand in Dumbledore's direction. "AccioHarry Potter's parchment."
Seconds later, Sirius Black snarled, "Bloody hell, Dumbledore, you're a bloody buggering moron!"
Three schools' worth of students and professors were shocked into silence in the entire Great Hall.
Sirius continued, "All the handwriting looks like Harry's—but a spell exists to mimic someone's handwriting, remember? Maybe the handwriting fooled you, but surelyyou noticed that this parchment says Harry is a student of Ilvermorny School of Witchcraft and Wizardry? That's in the USA!"
Then Sirius said sarcastically to Dumbledore, "In all the time you were bleating 'Join the other Champions' at my godson and ward, you never noticed that the parchment said the wrong school, in a country where Harry has never visited?"
"Harry still must compete, Sirius," Dumbledore declared with complete confidence. "This is what the rules say."
Sirius replied, "I don't think that's what the rules actuallysay, not even close." Sirius looked meaningfully at the bushy-haired witch to Harry's right.
Hermione now stood up at the Gryffindor table.
Hermione said loudly, "Headmaster, Mr Crouch and Mr Bagman, you either are willfully lying to Harry, your memories of the Triwizard Tournament rules have faded with age or you never have read the rules."
Disappointed-looking Dumbledore took a breath to speak—
—but Hermione was ready for him. "Shall I read to you the actual Tournament rules, not what you lot want the rules to say when you try to browbeat a famous fourteen-year-old boy?"
Hermione thrust up a powder-blue booklet. "This is the rulebook for the Triwizard Tournament that was passed out to all Beauxbatons students over seventeen. It's my source for the rules now, since for some strange, odd, unimaginable reason, the English-language version of the rulebook has not been available in the Hogwarts library in the past fortnight. I thank Madame Maxime for loaning me a copy of the French rulebook."
Hermione paused to drop Madame Maxime a curtsey.
Hermione continued, "Now, translating into English as I go—"
.
Section 9, Paragraph 1A. A magical person who wishes to participate in a contest signals his wish by writing his name with ink and quill on a parchment, and dropping that parchment into the Goblet's flame. The parchment may optionally contain other writing that specifies the contestant that the submitter wishes to become in a multi-contestant contest. The Goblet then binds the submitter of the parchment to the contest with a magical contract.
Section 9, Paragraph 1B. If the submitter is not selected for the contest, his or her binding magical contract dissipates with no magical effect on the submitter. However, when the Goblet selects a contestant, the Goblet magically binds the contestant to the rules of the contest that are specific to the contest.
Section 9, Paragraph 2. The Goblet checks for a written name on each submitted parchment, but the name does not matter when the Goblet chooses a contestant. The Goblet does not choose each contestant by referring to the written names of the submitters and comparing the suitability of the magical people with those names. Instead, the Goblet chooses each contestant by comparing the suitability of the magical people whom the Goblet identifies by the submitters' magical signatures. For a contest with multiple contestants, the Goblet chooses each contestant by both comparing the suitability of the magical people with the submitted magical signatures, and by reading the writing on each parchment that specifies a preferred contestant.
Section 9, Paragraph 3A. If due to a prank or an evil act, the name that is attached to a submitter's magical signature does not match the name that is written on the parchment, and this parchment is ejected by the Goblet to announce the selection of a contestant, the named person is not bound by the magical contract; but the falsely-named submitter is bound by the magical contract, the same as though he or she had submitted a parchment with his or her true name written on the parchment and the Goblet had selected him or her as contestant.
Section 9, Paragraph 3B. If however the named person, who is under no binding magical contract, enters the contest and the submitter does not enter the contest, the named person assumes the submitter's binding magical contract from the time he or she enters the contest.
Section 9, Paragraph 4A. If the Goblet selects a contestant who is under seventeen years of age, the selection is valid in only two possible ways: when within the first twenty-four hours after the selection, a parent or the guardian of the contestant speaks words that grant permission; or when within the first twenty-four hours after the selection, a parent or the guardian of the contestant speaks no words that refuse permission.
Section 9, Paragraph 4B. Otherwise, the underage submitter is deemed to be an invalid contestant, and the binding magical contract on him or her dissipates, with no magical effect on him or her. In this case, contest officials have the option of holding another Goblet of Fire drawing, but with the underage magical person prevented from submitting his name this time. (See Section 8 about redrawing contestants after a rejected drawing.)
.
Then Hermione glared at Dumbledore. "At the start of this term, Sirius was not Harry's guardian; the Dursleys were Harry's nonmagical guardians and you were Harry's magical guardian. I'll bet you planned to say as Harry's magical guardian, 'You must be a Champion,' and this would create a binding magical contract on Harry where none existed before. And/or you planned to browbeat Harry into performing in the First Task, then Paragraph 3B would work a Gotcha on him. Or maybe Paragraph 3B would sink its hooks into Harry as soon as he entered the Entrance Hall—you've been quite pushy about Harry going there."
Sirius said loudly, "Just to solve Harry's problem explicitly, and to make the situation clear to everyone"—Sirius glared at Ron—"it is obvious that Harry did not put his name in the Goblet. Harry even has given a magical oath saying so. Harry does not want to be a Triwizard Tournament Champion. So I as Harry Potter's oath-sworn godfather and guardian officially refuse permissionfor Harry to become a Triwizard Tournament Champion."
Harry felt some sort of magical effect, but it lasted only a second.
Hermione said, "Harry, you just flashed red. Which confirms what Paragraphs 4A and 4B say, that you're out of the Tournament."
Right when Hermione said this, Amelia Bones and a horde of Aurors burst into the Great Hall.
