LightReader

Chapter 5 - Chapter 5 – Silence Is an Accomplice

"Grief is a mirror: it shows who you are when no one's watching."

The room was full. But no one seemed to want to be there.

On the central table sat coffee, cookies, tissues. Clara had arranged everything with steady hands and tired eyes.

Beatriz walked in with slow steps. Her face was swollen, eyes red. Tissue in one hand, another in her pocket. She sniffled discreetly, but the sound sliced through the silence like a knife.

Helena came in behind her, headphones hanging around her neck, black band t-shirt, the look of someone who hadn't asked to be born—let alone to be here.

Arthur was already seated, legs crossed, wearing an expression of aggressive boredom.

Rubens, with deep dark circles under his eyes, looked like he'd aged ten years overnight. The folder with his brother's papers sat beside him, a silent reminder.

Marcos stood up.

"Thank you for coming. I know this isn't easy."

Arthur muttered, "For some, it's harder than for others."

Beatriz sniffled. Helena rolled her eyes.

"Arthur, please," said Rubens, his voice hoarse.

"I'm just stating the obvious. Someone has to."

Marcos ignored him.

"We're here because a boy died. And no one knows exactly how or why. But everyone knows something was wrong."

Beatriz clutched her tissue. Helena sat far from the others.

"He was sensitive," Beatriz said, her voice trembling. "He always was. Since he was little."

"And no one noticed he was sinking?" Marcos asked.

Beatriz shrank into herself.

"I… I tried. But he shut himself off. And I… I had so much going on."

Arthur let out a dry laugh.

"Like keeping up appearances. Top priority in this house."

Helena looked at him.

"You talk like you're better than everyone."

"I'm not better. I'm just not blind."

Rubens ran a hand over his face.

"I lost my brother. And now my nephew. In less than a week."

Beatriz sniffled louder. Clara offered another tissue. She refused.

"I didn't come here to be attacked," Beatriz said, her voice firmer. "I'm grieving. This isn't a courtroom."

Marcos stepped closer.

"It's not a courtroom. But it is a room full of accomplices."

Beatriz stood up.

"I'm not going to listen to this. Not today."

"Then when?" Arthur asked.

She didn't answer. She left the room with quick steps, tissue clenched in her hand like a shield.

Helena looked at the door. Then at Marcos.

"She won't talk. She never does. She just cries and hopes the world understands."

Marcos nodded.

"And you? Will you talk?"

Helena shrugged.

"I listen. I always have. But no one ever asked."

Rubens looked at her.

"You listened to what he said?"

"I listened to what he didn't say."

Silence.

Marcos sat down.

"Then let's start there. With what wasn't said."

Arthur crossed his arms.

"It's going to be a long morning."

The room felt emptier without Beatriz. But the air remained heavy — as if she'd left her grief lingering behind.

Marcos looked at Helena.

"You said you listened to what he didn't say. Explain that."

Helena fiddled with her headphones, as if she wanted to put them back on and disappear.

"He talked to himself. Sometimes he recorded things. Sometimes he just mumbled. But I listened."

Arthur scoffed.

"Everyone talks to themselves. It's not a crime."

"It wasn't just that," Helena said. "He spoke like he was answering someone."

Rubens frowned.

"Someone in the house?"

"I don't know. But once… I heard him say, 'I can't tell. They won't understand.'"

Marcos leaned forward.

"When was that?"

"About two days before… everything."

"And you didn't say anything?"

"I thought it was just another episode. He had those. And no one ever listened anyway."

Arthur crossed his arms again.

"So you listened, but not enough to care?"

"And you? You mocked him all the time."

"Because he was dramatic."

"Because he was asking for help."

Marcos cut in.

"He recorded things. Do you have any of those recordings?"

Helena hesitated.

"Maybe. On the radio. Or in his backpack. But I'm not sure if they're still there."

Rubens stood up.

"I want to hear them."

Marcos looked at him.

"Now you want to?"

"I need to. To understand. To… to know if I failed."

Arthur muttered, "Spoiler: you did."

Rubens didn't respond.

Helena left the room. She returned minutes later with an old radio and a backpack.

"There's a tape here. But it's worn out."

Marcos took the radio. Pressed the button. Static. Then, the heir's voice.

"If I speak, they'll call me crazy. If I stay silent, maybe I'll survive one more day."

Rubens closed his eyes. Arthur stared at the floor. Helena remained still.

Marcos thought:

Madness is just the name we give when someone sees what others pretend not to.

The tape continued.

"The butler knows. He pretends he doesn't. But he knows. And Clara… Clara heard it too. She just doesn't want to remember."

Marcos paused.

"This changes everything."

Rubens looked at him.

"What are you going to do?"

"What I always do. Dig. And if they don't find bones, I'll unearth the silences."

Arthur stood up.

"Good luck. Around here, even the silences lie."

The library was empty, except for Clara, sitting with an open book she wasn't reading. The butler was arranging volumes with obsessive precision.

Marcos entered without knocking.

"I need to speak with you both."

Clara looked up, but said nothing. The butler kept handling the books.

"I heard a recording. He said you knew, Butler. And that Clara heard something she doesn't want to remember."

The butler stopped. Turned slowly.

"The young man said many things. Not all of them made sense."

"But some did, didn't they?"

Clara closed the book.

"He was paranoid. Thought everyone was conspiring against him."

"Were they?"

Silence.

Marcos stepped closer.

"He said, 'If I stay silent, maybe I'll survive one more day.' That's not paranoia. That's fear."

The butler clasped his hands behind his back.

"Fear is common in this house. It wasn't his alone."

"Fear of what?"

"Of being seen for who we truly are."

Clara stood up.

"I did hear something. A conversation. In the hallway. He was talking to someone. But when I looked… no one was there."

"What was he saying?"

"That 'truth doesn't fit in a will.' That 'legacy is just a well-told lie.'"

Marcos took mental note.

"And why didn't you say anything before?"

"Because here, speaking is the same as condemning."

The butler stepped forward.

"The young man knew too much. And didn't know how to carry it."

"And did you help him carry it?"

"We helped hide it."

Marcos stared at them.

"So he wasn't crazy."

Clara looked down.

"No. Just alone."

The butler murmured:

"And when you're alone, even truth feels like delusion."

Marcos left the library with more questions than answers. But now he knew: their silence wasn't ignorance. It was a choice.

The room was dim, lit only by the lamp. Clara sat, tense. Helena beside her, holding the radio. Marcos stood like a judge without a robe.

"There's one more tape," Helena said. "Found it at the bottom of the backpack. He recorded it the day before."

Clara closed her eyes.

"You don't need to listen."

"It needs to be heard," said Marcos. "Because now, silence protects no one."

Helena pressed the button. The heir's voice came through—firmer, clearer.

"Clara knows. She saw. She heard. But she chose silence. Because if she spoke, the family name would turn to dust."

Clara shrank into herself.

"She was there. When the butler handed over the papers. When they said the will would be 'adjusted.' She heard everything."

Marcos looked at Clara.

"You were present during the forgery?"

Clara didn't answer.

"She told me, 'Stay out of this.' But how could I, when it's my name they're erasing?"

The tape stopped.

Silence.

Marcos stepped closer.

"You knew the will was altered. That he would be disinherited. That everything would be covered up."

Clara finally spoke.

"I tried to protect him. But he didn't want protection. He wanted justice."

"And you chose silence."

"Because here, justice is just a pretty word. And silence is survival."

Helena looked at Clara.

"You could've stopped all of it."

"No. I could've died with him."

Marcos took a deep breath.

"Now everyone knows. And silence is no longer an accomplice. It's a defendant."

Clara stood. Looked at them both.

"Then let the trial begin."

She left the room. Helena turned off the radio. Marcos stared into the void.

Some truths don't save. But they condemn with dignity.

More Chapters