Before Cliff could say anything else, I jumped straight into it.
"Ollie thinks the first verse should feature the piano as the main instrument. I say it's gotta be the guitar. That's where we're butting heads."
One sentence to sum up the debate, then I glanced at Ollie. "How about this—I'll go first with my take, then you give yours, and we all hash it out together? Sound good?" I cut in before he could protest, taking charge of the vibe.
Ollie rolled his eyes, clearly not thrilled .
I chuckled. "I'll take that as a yes." Then I turned back to Maxim and Cliff.
"In my head, I'm picturing this gradual build-up."
"Start with just vocals—stripped down, no frills, nothing extra. Then the guitar slides in, followed by the bass, then the drums. Even the drum kit could layer up—maybe toms first, then the kick drum. Bit by bit, it stacks the emotion, syncing perfectly with the melody and lyrics."
"When the chorus hits, that's where the piano comes in—adding depth and richness to the sound, letting all that built-up feeling explode ."
"The guitar strings—clear and bright—play a supporting role early on. They keep a low profile, not throwing off the song's balance, while blending with the lyrics' mood. Then the piano's full, thick tones dig into the emotion in the chorus, letting that deeper unease really settle in."
As I talked, my eyes lit up. Thoughts that were fuzzy before started snapping into focus—
I've never studied arranging formally. Most of what I've got is gut instinct and vibes, hard to pin down with words. But tonight? It's a chance. Talking it out, bouncing ideas around—it's like a faucet turned on in my brain. Stuff about instruments, melody texture, song style—it's all pouring out.
Little by little, it's getting clearer. It's kind of a messy, blurry process, but it's heading the right way. Fun, too.
I couldn't help getting pumped .
Truth is, songwriting and arranging? Two different beasts.
Most folks think "songwriting" just means whipping up a vocal melody or the main tune. Easy mistake. But technically, it's everything—creating all the parts and making something playable.
Back in the classical days, before computers, songwriting was the whole deal. Take a composer: they'd write the main melody, pair it with harmonies, pick the right instruments, then make sure it all worked for real players or singers—fully finished.
Arranging, though? That's a newer thing. It popped up as music got more polished and commercial—especially after the '90s when computers took over. No more needing a live band in a studio to test stuff out or tweak it on the spot. You could do it all digitally, mimicking real instruments crazy well. That's when arranging split off as its own gig.
Once the music industry went full-on industrial, every job got sliced up and specialized. One person might write the melody and chords, another handles keyboard parts, someone else tackles electric instruments—all arranging stuff.
So now, modern music splits like this:
Songwriter—usually the melody maker. Lyricist. Arranger—which can break down even more into roles like recording engineer, mix engineer, mastering engineer, you name it.
Could be different people for each. Could be one person doing it all.
Point is, today's "songwriting" is often just the vocal line or a specific instrumental bit. "Arranging" is the messy follow-up—writing the vocals, tweaking chords, picking and pairing instruments, tossing in effects, exporting the files, all that jazz.
An arranger's like a producer. First, they need deep music theory and instrument know-how. Second, they've got to have sharp instincts—nailing song style, market fit, what'll pop. Third, they need creative juice to tweak a track for different performers, pulling out unique flavors.
Same song, different arrangement? It could go pop, rock, jazz, folk—whatever. Hand it to different singers with fresh arrangements, and boom, new vibe. That's huge online these days. Killer covers? They're not karaoke—they're re-arranged.
Shows like The Voice or American Idol—contestants tweak songs all the time. That's arranging as a second creation: reworking the original (instruments, style, structure), tailoring it to the performer digitally, then mixing live band parts with pre-recorded tracks for the stage. You might see a solo piano moment pop up for effect .
Objectively, songwriting and arranging are both tough—way beyond what most people could handle. Songwriting leans hard on raw talent; arranging's more about stacking up knowledge.
As the industry went big-time, arrangers shot up in clout. Even the Grammys added a big award just for them—says it all.
A top-tier arranger can turn a meh song into something solid or a good one into a classic. Magic stuff.
Back to me—obviously, I'm barely scratching the arranging surface. It's all instinct and talent driving my ideas right now.
please vote this story to motivate me post 2ch/day
you can request story !!
patreon belamy20
always finish story
Visit my Patreon = belamy20
Grind is my Ninja way up to 1150
Play football with power of MUSIC!!(end)
KING OF MUSIC(end)
Actor in Hollywood up to 2000
american horror (end)
american drama (end)
horor hollywood (end)
Hollywood: titanic director(ed)
king of tennis (end)
uchiha patriarch(end)
hikari chat group (end)
king of music (end)
flame ninja (end)
puppet ninja (end)
ghoul in ninja world (end)
american life 1995
and more
"Σ(っ°Д°;)っ" 5$