Chapter 9: The Missing Package Mystery, Part 1 of 6
Monica Geller snapped the dry-erase marker against the smooth plastic of the clue board, the sharp click echoing in her living room. The three-foot-tall board leaned against the far wall, a chaotic mess of scribbles and theories. It's supposed to be organized. It's a board for solving a mystery, not the crime scene itself. Her core motivation—the desperate need for control—twisted into a phantom tightness in her chest, like an ill-fitting bridesmaid dress from her past.
The board bore Barney's illegible scrawls ("It was The Canadian Guy in the hat, he's a spy!"), Phoebe's frantic, multi-colored notes about "mailroom gremlins," and Ross's neat, boring labels ("Hypothesis A: Extinction Event"). Her sneakers scuffed the worn linoleum as she marched to the dining table, snatching the lone piece of evidence: a torn mailing label, ragged as if gnawed by a rat.
"Okay, people," Monica said, holding the paper up, her voice too loud, too tight. "The package is missing. The only thing we have is this, which Robin found in the mailroom trash. Anyone got a theory that doesn't involve the collective consciousness of pigeons?"
Robin Scherbatsky leaned back on the orange couch, twirling the ice in her scotch glass with a professional disinterest. The faint clink of the cubes punctuated her dry tone.
"It's a partial address. The city and state are gone, but the sender's name is still there. It says 'T. Pendergrass, Architects,'" Robin said, her blue eyes narrowing as she studied the label.
Ted Mosby's head lifted with an architect's sharp jolt, the name T. Pendergrass sparking a flutter under his navy peacoat. T. Pendergrass. He knew the name. The anxious tremor in his chest felt like a bird's wings beating against a cage.
"Wait, wait, wait," Ted said, pushing himself up from the armchair, running a hand through his tousled hair. His smile was eager, masking the professional anxiety. "T. Pendergrass… that's one of the biggest architectural firms on the East Coast. They did the renovation on the old G.E. building. Why would they mail a package to a residential apartment building in the Village?"
Ross adjusted his silk tie, his brown eyes lighting with academic zeal. "Well, that narrows it down, doesn't it? An architectural firm. Could be plans, blueprints, or perhaps a rare lithograph of the original Dakota building. The theft of which would suggest a highly coordinated, possibly paramilitary, operation—"
Ted cut him off, his Midwestern drawl speeding up. "Ross, this isn't The Da Vinci Code. It's a missing package."
"He's right," Monica said, stabbing at the clue board with her marker. "It was definitely T. Pendergrass. That's a start. Barney, get that 'Canadian Spy' garbage off my board."
Barney, sitting next to Joey, threw his hands up dramatically. "But the spy angle is legendary! He was clearly trying to secure the plans for a new, more awesome skyscraper to replace the Empire State Building!"
Joey leaned in, his wide grin infectious. "Oh, yeah! And then we gotta stop him, Bar. I'm thinking, a high-speed chase on top of the unfinished girders."
Phoebe Buffay, cross-legged on the floor, hummed a tuneless melody while fiddling with a tangled mass of wires, a cheap digital camera, and a bird feeder. Her blue eyes were dreamy, but her mouth set in an intense line. It's not gremlins, Monica. They're just misunderstood little mail-sorters.
"It's not gremlins, Monica. They're just misunderstood little mail-sorters," Phoebe said, twisting one of her layered necklaces—a tell of her mystic truth bomb. "But the pigeons… they're the eyes of the city. They see all. They know what fell from the sky and where the shadow-people hid it."
Marshall slapped his thigh with a booming laugh, his Viking pendant swinging against his flannel shirt. "That's gold, Phoebs! A pigeon camera! Genius! You've gotta paint that, Lily!"
Lily, sketching abstract shapes on a napkin, nodded, her green eyes alight. "A pigeon. On a tripod. With the mailroom in the background. It's commentary on surveillance art!"
Ted massaged the base of his neck, skepticism spiking. I'm trying to solve a crime involving a prestigious architecture firm, and we're talking about a pigeon camera.
Phoebe ignored him, securing the camera to the feeder with deft fingers. "The mailroom needs a witness," she declared, standing up. "And I have just the guy."
Joey pulled a crumpled script from his pocket, reading in a dramatic octave drop. "You see, the torn label is merely a ruse, a clever diversion to throw the authorities off the scent of… The Grand Mail Heist!"
Chandler, sipping coffee from a massive mug, didn't look up.
"I'm sorry, is this an audition, or is your new theory that The Grand Mail Heist is also the title of your failed play?" Chandler quipped, his tone dry.
Robin pushed off the couch, the tension a perfect mix of New York chaos and professional gravity. They're insane, but they're not boring.
"Alright, look," Robin said, her tone clipped, cutting through the noise. "Phoebe and Marshall can set up the bird cam. Ted, you can obsess over the architect's name. But the label is torn. It was mailed from somewhere. We need to know what they sell that would come in a package worth stealing."
She grabbed her leather jacket, a reporter's instinct kicking in. A good reporter hits the streets, not the clue board.
Rachel stepped forward, her green eyes wide with absorption. "I'll come with you! I'm good at shopping! We can… look for clues at the architect's supply store!"
Robin laughed, short and cynical. "Honey, we're not going to a supply store. We're going to a boutique. T. Pendergrass also designed a line of ridiculously expensive, minimalist home goods. They mail out gifts."
She gestured to Lily. "You wanna mediate a rivalry, Lil? Come with us. You can keep us from strangling each other over whether a scarf counts as a clue."
Lily grinned, tossing her sketchpad aside. "Done. Let's go watch my friend try to look professional in an architectural gift shop."
Ranjit's gentle, accented voice cut in from the entryway, where he waited in his navy cap. He adjusted it, his dark eyes twinkling.
"New York is a big place, girls. New paths await," Ranjit said, his tone calming the room's frantic pitch. "But a little rivalry keeps the wheels turning, no? Just make sure the cab gets paid."
Later, Marshall and Lily sat on the balcony, the city's distant hum a backdrop. He traced a pattern on her hand, the warmth of their connection a quiet anchor amid the mystery.
MORE POWER STONES == MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
Love [ Friends and HIMYM Crossover ]? Unlock More Chapters and Support the Story!
Dive deeper into the world of [ Friends and HIMYM Crossover ] with exclusive access to 35+ chapters on my Patreon, plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $5/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ Game Of Throne ,MCU and Arrowverse, Breaking Bad , The Walking dead ,The Hobbit,Wednesday].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!