Chapter 2: WELCOME TO MYSTIC FALLS HIGH
POV: Sam Barton
The hallways of Mystic Falls High buzz with the nervous energy of junior year's first week. Sam clutches his schedule—carefully orchestrated to intersect with the main cast—and reminds himself to breathe. These aren't characters anymore. They're real, living people who don't know they're months away from vampire attacks and life-shattering revelations.
His Enhanced Speed clone waited at home, practically vibrating with impatience.
"Let me come with you," it had argued. "I could scout, gather intel—"
"You're staying put," Sam had replied firmly. "A duplicate of me showing up at school would raise questions we can't answer."
Now, navigating the crowded corridor toward his locker, Sam second-guesses that choice. The clone's perspective would be useful. But the System's warning echoes in his mind: keep your abilities secret from everyone.
He rounds the corner and collides with a whirlwind of blonde hair and color-coded schedules.
Caroline Forbes goes down, her planner exploding across the floor like confetti—pink pages for cheer practice, yellow for student council, blue for academic commitments. Sam drops to his knees immediately, helping gather the scattered chaos.
"Oh God, I'm so sorry," Caroline says, frantically collecting pages. "I wasn't watching where I was—"
"My fault entirely," Sam interrupts, noting the stress radiating from her in tight shoulders and rapid breathing. Three extracurriculars, cheer practice, committee meetings—her schedule reads like a military operation. "Do you schedule bathroom breaks too, or is that too spontaneous?"
Caroline pauses, a genuine laugh escaping before she can stop it. She looks up at him—really looks—taking in the messy brown hair, the British accent bleeding through from his past life, the fact that he's actually listening instead of rushing away.
"She's beautiful," Sam realizes with a start. Not the superficial prettiness he remembered from the show, but something deeper. Intelligence sparking in blue eyes, determination in the set of her jaw, kindness in the way she immediately apologized for something that wasn't her fault.
"Sam Barton, right?" She stands, brushing dust from her cheerleading skirt. "The archaeology orphan?"
Sam winces. The nickname follows him everywhere in this town.
Caroline's face immediately transforms with mortification.
"Oh God, I'm sorry. That was—people call you that, but I shouldn't have—"
"It's fine," Sam says quickly, offering a self-deprecating smile. "Accurate, if not particularly creative."
Something shifts in Caroline's expression. Curiosity replaces embarrassment.
"You have an accent."
"Past life bleeding through." Sam shrugs.
"Spent some time in England with my parents before they died. Archaeological digs."
It's a practiced lie, but Caroline seems to accept it. She studies him with renewed interest—mysterious new kid with a tragic backstory and an exotic accent who actually sees the humor in her hyperorganized life.
"Well, Sam Barton," she says, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear, "welcome to Mystic Falls High. Fair warning: it's smaller than it looks, everyone knows everyone's business, and Mr. Tanner is a complete troll."
"Noted." Sam grins. "Any other survival tips?"
"Sit with the right people at lunch, don't cross Tyler Lockwood, and..." She pauses, biting her lower lip. "Maybe we could show you around? I mean, if you want. No pressure."
[SOCIAL INTERACTION DETECTED]
[CAROLINE FORBES: INTERESTED - POTENTIAL ROMANCE PATH IDENTIFIED]
[QUEST UPDATE: MAKE FRIENDS (1/3 COMPLETE)]
Sam's pulse quickens, though whether from the System notification or Caroline's smile, he can't tell.
"I'd like that," he says honestly.
The bell rings, breaking the moment. Caroline glances at her meticulously organized schedule.
"I have AP History with Tanner first period. You?"
Sam checks his own schedule—also AP History. Another coincidence that wasn't coincidence at all.
"Same."
Caroline's smile brightens.
"Perfect. Come on, I'll introduce you to everyone."
They walk through the hallways together, Caroline pointing out classrooms and offering commentary on teachers. Sam finds himself genuinely enjoying her company—the quick wit hidden beneath the perfect exterior, the way she notices details about people, the quiet vulnerability that flashes through her confidence.
"This isn't the Caroline from the show," he realizes. "This is a real person. Complex, layered, afraid she's too much for people to handle."
In AP History, they slide into seats near the back. Mr. Tanner stalks in moments later, his perpetual scowl already in place. Sam remembers him as a minor antagonist—the teacher who humiliated students and died early in the season. Seeing him in person, Sam mostly feels pity. A bitter man taking out his failures on teenagers.
"Welcome to AP History," Tanner announces, his voice dripping with disdain. "For those of you thinking this will be an easy A, I suggest transferring to basket weaving. Who can tell me the significance of the Battle of Mystic Falls?"
Several hands shoot up. Sam keeps his down—he knows the real answer involves vampires and founding families, not just Civil War history.
"Miss Bennett?" Tanner calls on Bonnie, who sits three rows ahead.
"The Confederate forces made their last stand here," Bonnie says confidently. "Twenty-seven soldiers died defending the town."
Sam's attention sharpens. Bonnie Bennett—soon to be one of the most powerful witches in the world, currently just a high school student with strange dreams. Her grandmother's occult knowledge lurks in her bloodline, waiting to explode into terrifying reality.
"Correct," Tanner says grudgingly. "Though 'defending' is generous. They were slaughtered. Mr. Barton—let's see what our new student knows. What role did Mystic Falls play in the larger conflict?"
Sam straightens. This is a test—not just of historical knowledge, but of how well he can blend in.
"Geographically, it controlled river access," he says carefully. "Small towns like this often became strategic chokepoints. The real question is why twenty-seven soldiers thought they could hold it against superior forces."
Tanner's eyes narrow with interest.
"And what's your theory?"
"Because they were protecting the tomb full of vampires beneath the church, but I can't exactly say that."
"Desperation," Sam replies. "Maybe they were protecting something—or someone—they couldn't afford to lose. Sometimes people make impossible stands when retreat isn't an option."
Caroline glances at him with newfound respect. Even Bonnie turns around, studying him with curious eyes.
"Interesting perspective," Tanner admits. "Perhaps you'll be more challenging than your classmates."
The class continues with Tanner's typical mix of historical fact and student humiliation. Sam takes notes, but his attention keeps drifting to the people around him. Elena Gilbert sits near the front, still wrapped in grief four months after her parents' accident. Her friend Bonnie tries to engage her, but Elena's responses are mechanical, distant.
"She's not ready for Stefan yet," Sam observes. "Still too broken. But that's exactly when vampires seem most appealing—when normal life feels impossible to bear."
When the bell rings, Caroline stands with him.
"Not bad," she says approvingly. "Tanner almost smiled. That might be a school record."
"I aim to please." Sam gathers his books. "What's next?"
"I have free period, but you probably want to find your locker. Building map?" She pulls out a color-coded guide from her planner.
"You really do have everything organized."
Caroline's cheeks pink slightly.
"Most people find it annoying."
"Most people are idiots," Sam thinks, but says, "Most people wish they had their lives half as together as you do."
The genuine compliment catches her off guard. For a moment, the confident mask slips, revealing something vulnerable underneath.
"Thank you," she says quietly. "That... means something."
They part ways at Sam's locker, Caroline heading to student council prep while Sam navigates toward gym class. The hallways thin out as students filter into classrooms, leaving him momentarily alone with his thoughts.
The clone's voice echoes in his mind through their shared connection: "How's it going? Meet anyone interesting?"
"Caroline Forbes," Sam responds mentally. "She's... not what I expected."
"Better or worse?"
Sam considers this as he changes into gym clothes in the locker room. Caroline from the show was beautiful but shallow, insecure and desperate for attention. Caroline in reality is beautiful and complex, insecure but covering it with genuine competence and drive.
"Just different. More real."
The gym teacher, Coach Williams, emerges with the swagger of someone who peaked in high school.
"New kid!" he bellows at Sam. "Barton, right? You play any sports?"
"Not seriously," Sam replies honestly. His past life involved more studying than athletics, though he'd taken some self-defense classes.
"Well, we'll see what you're made of. Touch football scrimmage today. You're with the shirts."
Sam joins the shirts team, noting with some amusement that his teammates include Matt Donovan and Tyler Lockwood—the quarterback and the future werewolf. In person, they're just teenagers figuring out their place in the social hierarchy.
Tyler sizes him up with typical jock appraisal.
"You any good, new kid?"
"Enhanced Speed would help here," Sam thinks, wishing his clone were present. "But regular human speed will have to do."
"We'll find out," Sam replies evenly.
The scrimmage begins as a barely disguised hazing ritual. Tyler immediately targets Sam, sending aggressive plays his way—testing the newcomer's mettle. Sam's medical knowledge helps him analyze movements, predict tackles, find openings. His PER stat, even at base level, gives him slightly better spatial awareness than a normal teenager.
When Tyler charges him with obvious intent to flatten, Sam sidesteps at the last second, redirecting the larger boy's momentum rather than trying to overpower him. Tyler stumbles but catches himself, surprise replacing aggression.
"Not bad," Tyler admits grudgingly.
"Lucky dodge," Sam deflects.
The next play, instead of going for personal glory, Sam focuses on team dynamics. He spots Matt breaking free on a crossing pattern and delivers a perfect pass—not spectacular, but smart. Matt grins as he hauls in the touchdown.
"Nice pass, man," Matt calls, offering a fist bump. "Most new guys try to be heroes on their first day."
"Heroes get you tackled," Sam replies, returning the bump. "Teamwork gets you wins."
[QUEST UPDATE: MAKE FRIENDS (2/3 COMPLETE)]
[NEW PASSIVE SKILL UNLOCKED: SOCIAL ADAPTATION]
[+1 CHA when successfully reading social situations]
Tyler jogs over, his earlier hostility replaced with respect.
"You're quick," he says, and something in his voice suggests approval. "And you pass. That's... rare."
Sam shrugs, but internally notes the successful integration. These boys aren't enemies—they're potential allies who don't know they'll need superhuman help to survive the next few years.
After gym, Sam heads to lunch with a growing sense of confidence. Two friends made, Caroline interested, social dynamics navigating successfully. The cafeteria buzzes with typical teenage energy—cliques at their established tables, gossip flowing like currency.
Caroline waves him over to her table, where she sits with a mix of cheerleaders and student council members. Sam recognizes some faces from the show, but they're younger here, less defined by future tragedies.
"Everyone, this is Sam," Caroline announces. "The new guy I was telling you about."
Introductions flow around the table. Sam smiles, makes appropriate responses, but his attention keeps drifting to a table near the windows where Elena Gilbert sits with Bonnie Bennett. They're deep in conversation, Elena's grief still visible in the dark circles under her eyes.
"Stefan arrives soon," Sam remembers. "Maybe today, maybe tomorrow. When he does, everything changes."
Caroline follows his gaze.
"That's Elena Gilbert and Bonnie Bennett," she says softly. "Elena's parents died in May. Car accident on Wickery Bridge."
"The accident that saved her life," Sam thinks grimly. "If she'd been in that car, Klaus would have had to wait another generation for a doppelganger."
"Terrible," he says aloud, meaning it.
"Bonnie's been trying to help, but..." Caroline shrugs. "Grief has its own timeline, you know?"
Sam does know. He also knows that Elena's grief will make her vulnerable to a certain brooding vampire who promises escape from pain. The thought of that inevitable meeting fills him with dread.
"Unless I change the dynamic. Unless I help her heal before Stefan can offer false comfort."
It's a dangerous game—altering canon events without knowing the full consequences. But Sam can't just sit back and watch people he's growing to care about fall into supernatural traps.
The lunch period passes quickly. Caroline walks with him to his next class, chattering about teachers and school events. Sam finds himself genuinely enjoying her company, which complicates things. In the show, Caroline gets turned into a vampire early in the season—a transformation that nearly destroys her but ultimately makes her stronger.
"Can I prevent that?" Sam wonders. "Should I?"
It's a question that haunts him through the rest of the day. Each class, each conversation, each moment of normal teenage life feels fragile, temporary. These people don't know what's coming. They can't know.
By the final bell, Sam has successfully integrated into Mystic Falls High's social ecosystem. Teachers acknowledge him, classmates include him, and Caroline Forbes has definitely marked him as someone worth knowing better.
As students flood out of the building, Caroline catches up to him in the parking lot.
"So," she says, tucking a strand of hair behind her ear in a gesture Sam is learning to recognize as nervous energy, "there's this thing tomorrow night. Back-to-School Bonfire at the Lockwood's. You should come."
"The bonfire where Vicki Donovan gets attacked by Damon," Sam's memory supplies. "First vampire encounter of the series."
"I'd like that," he says honestly. And he would—both to spend time with Caroline and to be present when the supernatural chaos begins. Maybe he can prevent Vicki's attack, save her from becoming a vampire only to die anyway.
"Great!" Caroline's smile lights up her whole face. "I'll text you the details."
They exchange phone numbers, a small moment that feels significant in ways Sam can't fully explain. As Caroline drives away in her convertible, Sam stands in the parking lot processing the day.
His phone buzzes with a mental connection from his clone: "How did it go?"
"Better than expected," Sam responds. "Caroline's amazing. Made friends with Matt and Tyler. Started building the network we'll need."
"Any sign of Stefan Salvatore?"
Sam scans the parking lot one more time. No sign of the classic Porsche 911 that signals the vampire's arrival.
"Not yet. But soon."
The drive home gives him time to think. Tonight, he'll review his parents' research, prepare vervain protection for his new friends, and plan for the bonfire. The clone will need better training in Enhanced Speed mastery—their lives may depend on superhuman abilities very soon.
But underneath the strategic planning, a deeper realization settles in. These people aren't just pieces on a supernatural chess board. They're becoming his friends, his anchors to humanity in a world about to go insane. Caroline's laugh, Matt's easy friendship, even Tyler's grudging respect—they matter in ways that transcend plot knowledge.
"I can't save everyone by staying detached," Sam understands. "I have to care about them as people, not characters. Even if that makes losing them hurt more."
The Barton estate comes into view, isolated and quiet. His clone will be waiting for a full debrief, eager for action after a day of enforced inactivity. Tomorrow brings the bonfire, Damon's arrival, and the first real supernatural incident.
But tonight, Sam allows himself a moment of simple satisfaction. Day one at Mystic Falls High: successful. Caroline Forbes: interested. Social foundation: established.
Now the real work begins.
[QUEST COMPLETE: MAKE FRIENDS (3/3)]
[EXP GAINED: +100]
[CURRENT EXP: 150/150 TO LEVEL 2]
[LEVEL UP ACHIEVED!]
[+5 STAT POINTS AVAILABLE]
[NEW ABILITY UNLOCKED: CLONE TELEPATHY]
[Range: 1 mile, allows mental communication with active clones]
Sam grins as he pulls into the driveway. Level 2 already, and the real adventure hasn't even started yet.
Time to get stronger.
+1 CHAPTER AFTER EVERY 3 REVIEWS
MORE POWER STONES == MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
Love [ The Vampire Diaries: The Clone Sovereign ]? Unlock More Chapters and Support the Story!
with exclusive access to 27+ chapters on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!