Chapter 11: HEIST WHISPERS
Jake had been acting suspicious for three days.
Not regular-Jake-suspicious, which involved forgotten paperwork and unauthorized desk modifications. This was special-occasion-suspicious—the kind of energy that preceded elaborate schemes.
I knew what was coming. I'd watched it happen on screen a dozen times.
The Halloween Heist.
Monday morning, Jake made his move.
"Captain Holt." He stood in the doorway of Holt's office with the solemnity of a diplomat presenting a treaty. "I would like to propose a wager."
Holt looked up from his paperwork. "No."
"You haven't heard the wager yet."
"I don't need to. Any wager proposed by you will inevitably involve childish behavior, unprofessional conduct, and a waste of department resources."
"Okay, but what if I told you the winner gets to make the loser do their paperwork for a month?"
Something flickered in Holt's expression. Interest, quickly suppressed.
"Continue."
Jake grinned and launched into his pitch. The Medal of Valor—Holt's prized commendation from his days in the field—would be locked in a display case in the bullpen. Whoever possessed it at midnight on Halloween won the bet.
"Simple," Jake concluded. "Elegant. A test of cunning and determination."
"It's juvenile."
"It's legendary." Jake leaned forward. "Captain, I'm offering you the chance to prove that experience and discipline beat creativity and chaos. Unless you're worried you can't win?"
The silence stretched.
Then Holt's lips pressed together in what might, on a more expressive face, have been a smile.
"Detective Peralta. You have yourself a wager."
[99th Precinct — Lunch Break]
The announcement spread through the bullpen like wildfire.
Amy immediately started making contingency binders. Charles pledged undying loyalty to Jake ("I'll be your rock, your sword, your cheese-related distraction!"). Rosa observed the chaos with something approaching amusement. Terry tried to mediate, failed, and went to lift weights instead.
I sat at my desk, watching the chaos, and felt the System stir.
[MISSION AVAILABLE: Win the Halloween Heist] [Rank: S] [Reward: 3000 EXP, Title "Heist Contender"] [Deadline: October 31st, 11:59 PM] [Accept?]
Three thousand experience points.
That was... significant. My current level-up threshold was 350. Three thousand would blow through multiple levels, potentially unlocking abilities I hadn't even seen yet.
"The System recognizes opportunity, Host. This isn't just a precinct game—it's a strategic challenge with meaningful rewards. Jake wins in your memories of the show. But you're here now. You're a variable. The question is: do you want to play?"
I accepted the mission.
The notification confirmed with a subtle pulse of acknowledgment.
"Excellent choice. Now comes the hard part: developing a strategy that beats both a chaotic improviser AND a meticulous planner, without either of them realizing you're competing."
Easier said than done.
[Holt's Office — 2:15 PM]
The captain called me in with a gesture that somehow communicated both professionalism and conspiracy.
"Detective Cole. Close the door."
I closed the door.
"I understand you've developed a reputation for strategic thinking. The bodega case. The Vulture situation." Holt's hands were folded in their usual precise configuration. "I find myself in need of... auxiliary support."
"For the heist?"
"For maintaining proper order in this precinct." He paused. "Which happens to involve winning a wager against Detective Peralta."
[RAYMOND HOLT] [Standing: +18 (Recruiting)]
"He wants your help. Interesting. What are you going to tell him?"
"I appreciate the offer, Captain. But I think I should stay neutral in this particular competition."
Holt studied me for a long moment. "Neutral."
"It seems like the professional choice."
"Indeed." He returned to his paperwork. "Dismissed."
I left his office feeling his analytical gaze follow me across the bullpen.
[Jake's Desk — 3:45 PM]
"Cole! My man! My partner! My brother from another procedural!"
Jake draped an arm over my shoulders with the enthusiasm of someone about to ask a favor.
"The heist," he said conspiratorially. "I need you."
"I'm staying neutral, Jake."
"Neutral? Neutral is for Switzerland and breakfast foods. This is WAR, Cole. A war between fun and boring, between creativity and conformity, between—"
"Jake."
"—justice and tyranny—"
"Jake."
He stopped. "Yeah?"
"I'm not joining your team. Or Holt's team. I'm just going to enjoy the festivities."
Jake's expression cycled through confusion, betrayal, and finally grudging acceptance. "You're pulling a Rosa. Just watching from the sidelines while the rest of us fight and bleed and steal medals."
"Something like that."
"Fine. But when I win—and I WILL win—you have to admit that my victory was incredible."
"Deal."
He wandered off, presumably to find more willing accomplices.
[JAKE PERALTA] [Standing: +56 → +55 (Slight disappointment)]
"Playing both sides requires balance, Host. You've declined both offers, which means both players now view you as a missed asset rather than an active threat. That's cover—but it won't last if they start comparing notes."
I knew. I needed to move fast.
[Marcus's Apartment — 11:30 PM]
The precinct layout spread across my coffee table like a battle map.
I'd sketched it from memory—desks, hallways, Holt's office, the evidence room, the break room, every camera position and blind spot. Hours of walking those halls had burned the geography into my brain.
The medal would be in a locked display case in the bullpen. Both Jake and Holt would have keys. The game was simple: possess the medal at midnight.
Jake's strategy, if it followed canon, would involve elaborate misdirection, multiple fake medals, and chaotic last-minute pivots. Holt's strategy would be methodical, patient, focused on securing the genuine article while anticipating Jake's chaos.
Neither of them expected a third player.
That was my advantage.
"You're taking this seriously, Host."
"It's an S-Rank mission. Three thousand experience points. Of course I'm taking it seriously."
"Mmm. And it has nothing to do with wanting to prove you can beat both of them at their own game?"
I added another note to my diagram: camera blind spot near the evidence room, approximately four-second window.
"Maybe a little."
"Good. Pride is a useful motivator. Just don't let it make you sloppy."
The plan was forming. I couldn't out-chaos Jake or out-plan Holt individually. But I could exploit the collision between them—the moment when they were so focused on each other that they forgot to watch their flanks.
I needed allies. People inside both camps who could feed me information and create opportunities.
Charles was Jake's obvious weak point. His loyalty was legendary, but his need to feel valued was stronger.
Amy was Holt's most likely recruit. Her organizational skills made her invaluable, but her competitive streak could be redirected.
Two recruits. Two moles. One target.
"Strategic asset management, Host. You're learning."
I texted Charles: "Coffee tomorrow? Need to ask you something."
Then Amy: "Quick question about evidence procedures. Lunch?"
The pieces were moving.
MORE POWER STONES And REVIEWS== MORE CHAPTERS
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!