Chapter 4: Echoes
George woke to sunlight streaming through unfamiliar windows and the smell of coffee.
For a disoriented moment, he didn't know where he was. The bed was too soft, the room too bright, the sounds from the street below wrong for his apartment. Then memory returned—Vanessa's apartment, the mass casualty, collapsing into her bed still wearing his scrubs.
He sat up slowly, wincing as his right leg protested. Eight hours of surgery followed by inadequate sleep had left him stiff and aching. The bedside clock read 6:47 AM. His shift started at seven.
Shit.
George stumbled out of bed and found his phone on the nightstand—plugged in and charging, because of course Vanessa had thought of that. Thirteen missed calls from the hospital, six text messages, all from last night's attendings updating him on his patients.
All stable. All alive.
He should have felt relief. Instead, he felt the familiar weight of borrowed time, of four lives saved on a foundation of lies.
"You're awake." Vanessa appeared in the doorway, already dressed in a sleek business suit, her hair pulled back. She looked like she'd stepped out of a magazine. George looked down at his wrinkled, blood-stained scrubs and felt acutely aware of the gap between them.
"I need to get to the hospital," he said.
"I know. I laid out clean scrubs in the bathroom. They're Derek Shepherd's—he left them here after the charity gala last month." She held up a hand before George could ask. "Long story. My mother's on the hospital board. Derek got drunk and needed somewhere to crash that wasn't his house because Meredith was mad at him about something."
George blinked. "You're friends with Derek Shepherd?"
"I'm friends with everyone, George. It's what happens when your family donates millions to medical research." She handed him a travel mug. "Coffee. Black, two sugars, the way you like it. Bathroom's down the hall. You have eight minutes."
He made it to the hospital with three minutes to spare, arriving just as Bailey was posting the surgical board. She glanced at him, and something flickered across her face—the same expression she'd had on his first day, gone too quickly to identify.
"Dr. Matthews. You're on post-op rounds this morning. Check on your trauma patients from yesterday, then join me in the clinic at ten."
"The clinic?"
"You think attending trauma surgeons are too good for clinic duty?" Bailey's eyebrow arched in that way that used to make George want to sink into the floor. "Everyone rotates through. Even you."
"Yes, ma'am—Dr. Bailey."
She studied him for a moment longer than necessary. "Your patients did well yesterday. The construction worker in 4012 is already demanding to go home. The woman in 4015 is still critical but stable. Good work."
"Thank you."
Bailey nodded and walked away, leaving George standing in the hallway with the uncomfortable sensation that she'd been looking for something in his face and hadn't quite found it.
The post-op rounds were routine. George checked vitals, examined wounds, adjusted pain medication. The construction worker—Marcus, fifty-three, father of two—grabbed George's hand when he entered the room.
"Doc, they said you saved my life."
"I just did my job."
"Yeah, well, your job meant I get to see my daughter graduate next month." Marcus's eyes were wet. "So thank you. For doing your job."
George extracted his hand gently. "I'm glad you're doing well. The orthopedic team will be by later to discuss your leg. You'll need physical therapy, but you should make a full recovery."
He left before Marcus could thank him again. Gratitude always felt unearned, like he was accepting credit for something George O'Malley had done while wearing Gideon Matthews's face.
The Jane Doe from his first solo trauma was in 4018, still unconscious but stable. George reviewed her chart—kidney function acceptable, no signs of infection, vitals strong. Young, healthy, lucky.
He was checking her pupils when she stirred.
"Easy," George said automatically, his hand on her shoulder. "You're in the hospital. You're safe."
Her eyes opened—brown, confused, terrified. "Where—what—"
"Seattle Grace Hospital. You were hit by a car three days ago. Can you tell me your name?"
She blinked, processing. "Emma. Emma Chen."
George's hand froze on her shoulder. "Chen?"
"Yeah. Is that—is that weird? Why are you looking at me like that?"
Chen. Of course it's Chen. The universe has a sick sense of humor.
"No, it's not weird. I just—I know someone with that last name." George forced himself to move, to check her over professionally. "Do you remember what happened, Emma?"
"I was crossing the street. There was a car, it was going too fast, and then—" She stopped. "Nothing. I don't remember anything else."
"That's normal with head trauma. The memories might come back, or they might not." George made notes in her chart. "You're very lucky. You lost your spleen and one kidney, but you're going to be okay."
"My kidney?" Emma's voice climbed toward panic.
"You can live a perfectly normal life with one kidney. You'll need to be careful, stay hydrated, avoid certain medications, but you'll be fine."
Emma closed her eyes, tears leaking from the corners. "My parents are going to kill me. I was supposed to be at work. They don't even know where I am."
"We've been trying to reach your family. You didn't have ID on you."
"My purse. I must have dropped it." She opened her eyes again. "Can you call them? Please? My phone was in my purse, but I can give you their number."
George wrote down the contact information and promised to call personally. When he left the room, he found himself standing in the hallway, staring at the name he'd written.
Emergency Contact: James and Li Chen, Vancouver, BC.
It was a common name. Thousands of Chens in Vancouver. No reason to think they were related to Vanessa's family.
Except George had stopped believing in coincidence around the time he'd died and been resurrected with a stranger's face.
He pulled out his phone and texted Vanessa: Patient from my first trauma. Emma Chen. Parents in Vancouver. Related to you?
The response came within seconds: Cousin. Dad's brother's daughter. Oh my God. Is she okay?
George leaned against the wall and tried to breathe through the sudden tightness in his chest.
He'd saved Vanessa's cousin. The woman lying in that hospital bed was family to the family that had saved him. The circle was too perfect, too neat, too much like fate trying to tell him something.
She's stable. Lost a spleen and kidney but will recover. Should I tell her who I am?
Three dots appeared and disappeared multiple times. Finally: No. Not yet. But I'm coming to the hospital. I need to see her.
George pocketed his phone and made his way to the nurses' station, where he found Meredith charting and looking exhausted.
"Rough night?" he asked.
She looked up and smiled, but it didn't reach her eyes. "Couldn't sleep. Kept thinking about yesterday. All those people hurt, all that trauma." She set down her pen. "How do you do it? Trauma, day in and day out. How do you not let it break you?"
"Who says it doesn't?"
Meredith laughed, surprised. "That's refreshingly honest."
"You asked." George leaned against the counter, keeping his weight off his right leg. "I think we all break a little. The job is figuring out how to keep working while you're in pieces."
"Dark. I like it." Meredith studied him. "Did you sleep at all last night?"
"A few hours."
"Where? You look like you showered in someone else's bathroom."
Because I did. "Friend's place. Closer than mine."
"Hm." Meredith's eyes narrowed slightly. "What friend? You've been in Seattle all of five minutes."
"Old friend. From before." George could feel the lie getting away from him, compounding. "We reconnected when I took the job."
"Is this friend single?"
"Why?"
"Because you're blushing, which means either you're sleeping with them or you want to be." Meredith grinned. "I'm not judging. I'm nosy. There's a difference."
"It's complicated."
"It always is." She returned to her chart, but there was something thoughtful in her expression now. "Bring them to Joe's sometime. The bar across the street. That's where we do post-shift decompression. You should come anyway—you're part of the team now."
George's throat tightened. "I don't want to intrude."
"You're not intruding. I'm inviting you." Meredith looked up again. "Come on, Gideon. You can't work here and not be part of the social ecosystem. That's how you end up isolated and miserable."
I'm already isolated and miserable. At least I'm consistent.
"I'll think about it," George said.
"Think fast. We're going tonight after shift. No excuses."
Before George could respond, his pager went off. Bailey, summoning him to the clinic. He excused himself and made his way downstairs, where he found Bailey already seeing patients with brutal efficiency.
"Dr. Matthews." She handed him a chart without looking up. "Exam room three. Possible appendicitis. Do a workup and report back."
The clinic was exactly as George remembered—understaffed, overcrowded, full of people who needed help but couldn't afford the ER. He moved through patients on autopilot: the appendicitis (confirmed, admitted for surgery), a kid with a broken arm (sent to ortho), an elderly woman with chest pain (admitted for cardiac workup).
Between patients, he found Bailey watching him.
"You're good at this," she observed.
"At what?"
"Talking to people. Making them feel heard." Bailey crossed her arms. "Most trauma surgeons have terrible bedside manner. They're adrenaline junkies who only care about the dramatic saves. You actually listen."
"Trauma patients are still patients. They deserve compassion."
"Hm." Bailey's eyes narrowed. "You sound like someone I used to know."
George's heart stopped. "Oh?"
"Best resident I ever trained. Kind, compassionate, sometimes too soft for his own good. He'd spend hours with patients, learning their stories, treating them like people instead of cases." Bailey's voice had gone distant, remembering. "He died saving someone. Gave his life without hesitation because that's who he was."
George couldn't breathe. Couldn't speak. Could only stand there while Miranda Bailey mourned him to his face.
"George O'Malley," Bailey continued. "If you ever meet someone like that, Dr. Matthews, you hold onto them. The world doesn't make enough people like George."
"I'm sorry you lost him," George managed.
Bailey's eyes snapped back to the present, and for a moment—just a moment—George thought she saw something. But then she blinked and the moment passed.
"We all lost him. This hospital's been colder since he died." She handed George another chart. "Exam room five. Possible fracture. Get to work."
George escaped to exam room five and leaned against the closed door, his hands shaking. Bailey had compared him to himself. Had seen echoes of George O'Malley in Gideon Matthews's bedside manner.
She was getting too close.
They were all getting too close.
He needed to pull back, create distance, stop letting them see the person underneath the mask. But George had never been good at emotional walls, and apparently dying and getting a new face hadn't changed that fundamental flaw.
The patient in exam room five was a twelve-year-old girl with a suspected wrist fracture from skateboarding. George examined her gently, talking her through each step, and tried not to think about Bailey's words echoing in his head.
The world doesn't make enough people like George.
Maybe not. But the world had one George O'Malley, and he was so busy lying to everyone he loved that he was barely a person anymore.
Vanessa arrived at the hospital at two PM, looking calm and collected despite the fact that her cousin was lying in a hospital bed three floors up. George met her in the lobby, and the relief on her face when she saw him was palpable.
"Where is she?" Vanessa asked.
"Fourth floor. Room 4018. I haven't told her about us—about me. I wanted to check with you first."
"Good." Vanessa started toward the elevators. "My uncle doesn't know about you. About what my family did to save you. He thinks you're just someone I'm dating."
"Are we dating?"
She stopped and turned to face him. "Are we?"
George thought about the kiss, the nights at her apartment, the way she held him together when he was falling apart. "I don't know what we are."
"Honest answer. I can work with that." Vanessa pressed the elevator call button. "For now, you're just my boyfriend who happens to be the surgeon who saved Emma's life. Can you do that?"
"Lie to more people I care about? I'm getting pretty good at it."
Vanessa winced. "George—"
"I'm sorry. That wasn't fair." He ran a hand through his hair. "Yes. I can do that. But at some point, we need to talk about what happens when everyone finds out."
"I know." The elevator arrived and they stepped inside. "But not today. Today I just need to see my cousin alive and thank you for saving her."
Emma was awake and alert when they entered her room. Her face lit up when she saw Vanessa.
"Nessa! Oh my God, how did you—" She stopped, looking between Vanessa and George with sudden understanding. "Wait. You're dating my surgeon?"
"Apparently I have a type," Vanessa said dryly. She moved to Emma's bedside and took her hand. "Your parents are on their way. Flight lands in two hours."
"They're going to kill me."
"They're going to hug you until you can't breathe, and then they're going to ground you until you're thirty." Vanessa smoothed Emma's hair back from her forehead. "You scared everyone, Em."
"I scared myself." Emma looked at George. "He said I lost a kidney. Is that true?"
"Yes. But you're young and healthy. You'll adapt." George checked her chart, giving them space for family reunion. "Pain level?"
"Like a six? It hurts but it's manageable."
"I'll have the nurse increase your medication." He made a note. "Your parents will want to talk to me about your prognosis. I'll make myself available when they arrive."
"Thank you, Dr. Matthews. For saving my life."
There it was again. That gratitude he didn't deserve, offered by someone who had no idea how interconnected their lives were.
"Just doing my job," George said, and escaped before Vanessa could see his face.
He made it to the attendings' lounge before the emotion hit. George collapsed onto one of the leather couches and pressed his palms against his eyes, trying to breathe through the overwhelming weight of it all.
He'd saved Emma Chen. Vanessa's cousin. The daughter of the man whose brother had rebuilt George's face. The universe was drawing lines between everyone he touched, connecting dots he couldn't see, building toward some inevitable conclusion.
"You look like you need this more than I do."
George looked up to find Alex Karev holding out a bottle of water. He took it automatically.
"Thanks."
Alex dropped onto the couch across from him. "Heard you saved Emma Chen. The Chen family. That's the pharmaceutical empire Chens, right?"
"Yeah."
"Damn. They're going to love you. Probably donate another wing to the hospital in your honor." Alex twisted the cap off his own water bottle. "You know them? The family?"
"I know Vanessa Chen."
"The hot one who's always at fundraisers?" Alex's eyebrows rose. "How do you know her?"
She spent two years and hundreds of millions of dollars saving my life after I died for her.
"We're friends," George said carefully.
"Friends." Alex smirked. "Right. Because the way she looked at you when you were talking to Emma was definitely just friendship."
George's head snapped up. "You were watching?"
"I was checking on my patient across the hall. Couldn't help but notice the reunion." Alex leaned back, studying George with an intensity that was uncomfortable. "You seem familiar. We met before you took this job?"
"I don't think so."
"Hm. I'm usually good with faces." Alex shrugged. "Whatever. Welcome to the team, Matthews. Try not to let the Chen family adopt you. Rich people get weird about obligation."
He left before George could respond.
Two people in two days had said George seemed familiar. Bailey had compared him to his former self. Cristina knew he was lying. Meredith felt something she couldn't name.
The walls were closing in.
George's phone buzzed. A text from Cristina: OR 2, 3 PM. I'm doing a Whipple. You're observing.
He texted back: Why?
Because I want to see how you handle prolonged surgery. Also I'm testing a theory.
What theory?
You'll see.
George pocketed his phone and tried not to feel like he was walking into a trap.
OR 2 at three PM was exactly where George didn't want to be—locked in a room with Cristina Yang for what would probably be a six-hour surgery with nowhere to hide.
Cristina was already scrubbed when George entered the gallery. She glanced up at him through the glass and gestured for him to come down.
"I said observe," George called through the intercom.
"I changed my mind. Scrub in. My resident's incompetent and I need someone who knows what they're doing."
It wasn't a request.
George scrubbed in and entered the OR to find Cristina standing over a fifty-year-old man with pancreatic cancer. The Whipple procedure—pancreaticoduodenectomy—was one of the most complex surgeries in general surgery. It took hours, required precision, and showed exactly what kind of surgeon you were.
George took his position across from Cristina and tried to remember how to breathe.
"Scalpel," Cristina said, and the surgery began.
For the first hour, they worked in silence. George fell into the rhythm of it—suction here, retraction there, anticipating Cristina's needs before she voiced them. They moved around each other like dancers, and it was so familiar, so right, that George forgot to be careful.
"You've done this before," Cristina said.
"I've done Whipples, yes."
"Not just Whipples. You've done them with me." She didn't look up from the surgical field. "The way you're retracting—that's exactly where I need it before I ask. The way you're suctioning—you know my blind spots. We have a rhythm."
George's hands went still. "Cristina—"
"Don't bullshit me, Matthews. I've been doing this long enough to know when someone's worked with me before." She tied off a vessel, her movements precise despite the tension in her voice. "So either you've been secretly observing my surgeries for years, or we've scrubbed in together. Which is it?"
"We haven't scrubbed in together."
"Then explain why you move like you've been my resident."
Because I was. Because we did hundreds of surgeries together. Because you taught me that cardio was art and I taught you that people mattered more than hearts.
"I can't," George said quietly.
Cristina looked up then, her eyes meeting his over the patient. "Can't or won't?"
"Both."
They stared at each other across the table, the monitors beeping steadily, the patient's life literally in their hands.
"I could make this difficult for you," Cristina said. "Report you to the board. Demand an investigation into your credentials."
"I know."
"But I'm not going to. You know why?"
"Why?"
"Because you're a good surgeon and this patient deserves the best." Cristina returned her attention to the surgical field. "But Matthews? Eventually I'm going to figure out who you really are. And when I do, you better have a damn good explanation."
They finished the surgery in silence.
Six hours later, the patient was closed and stable, headed to recovery with an excellent prognosis. George stripped off his gloves and gown, exhaustion making his hands clumsy.
Cristina cornered him in the scrub room.
"I know you're lying about Hopkins," she said without preamble. "I know you've worked at Seattle Grace before, probably as a resident. I know you have some connection to this place that you're hiding."
"Cristina—"
"I'm not done." She stepped closer. "What I don't know is why. Why come back under a fake name? Why pretend to be someone you're not? What are you running from?"
"I'm not running from anything."
"Then what?"
George looked at her—brilliant, relentless Cristina Yang, who never let anything go, who saw through every lie—and wanted desperately to tell her the truth.
It's me. It's George. I'm alive and I'm right here and I'm so sorry I let you think I was dead.
But the words wouldn't come. Because telling Cristina meant telling everyone, and George wasn't ready for the world to know George O'Malley had risen from the grave wearing someone else's skin.
"I can't tell you," he said instead. "Not yet. But I promise, Cristina, I'm not here to hurt anyone. I'm just... I'm trying to do good work and help people. That's all."
Cristina studied him for a long moment. "You're protecting someone."
It wasn't a question, but George answered anyway. "Yes."
"Who?"
"Everyone. Myself. I don't know anymore."
Something in Cristina's expression softened, just slightly. "You're an idiot, Matthews. Whatever you're hiding, it's going to come out. It always does. And the longer you wait, the worse it's going to be."
"I know."
"So why not just tell the truth now?"
"Because I don't know how." George's voice cracked. "I don't know how to explain what happened without destroying everything."
Cristina was quiet for a moment. Then she said, "George O'Malley was my friend. One of the few people I actually gave a shit about. When he died, I lost someone I couldn't replace."
George couldn't breathe.
"If he was alive—if somehow, impossibly, he'd survived—I'd want to know. Even if the truth was complicated. Even if it hurt. Because knowing he was alive would be better than thinking he was dead." Cristina met his eyes. "You understand what I'm saying?"
"I understand."
"Good." She turned to leave, then paused at the door. "Whoever you're protecting, Matthews. Make sure they're worth it."
She left him alone in the scrub room, and George collapsed against the sink, shaking.
Cristina knew. Maybe not the specifics, maybe not the details, but she knew something was fundamentally wrong with his story. And she'd just told him, as clearly as she could without saying the words, that if George O'Malley was alive, she'd want to know.
Even if it hurt.
Even if the truth destroyed everything.
George pulled out his phone and texted Vanessa: I can't do this anymore.
Her response was immediate: Where are you?
Hospital. Scrub room outside OR 2.
Stay there. I'm coming.
She found him ten minutes later, still leaning against the sink, trying to remember how to be a person instead of a collection of lies.
"What happened?" Vanessa asked.
"Cristina. She knows I'm lying. She doesn't know what about, but she knows. And she told me—" George's voice broke. "She told me that if George was alive, she'd want to know. That it would be better than thinking he was dead."
Vanessa closed the door and crossed to him, pulling him into her arms. "What do you want to do?"
"I want to tell her. I want to tell all of them. But I'm terrified."
"Of what?"
"Of them hating me. Of losing them all over again, but this time it'll be my fault." George buried his face in her shoulder. "At least when I was dead, they remembered me fondly. If I tell them now, after all these lies, they'll hate me. And I'll deserve it."
"You don't know that."
"Don't I?" He pulled back. "I let them mourn me. I let my mother bury an empty casket. I came back and lied to their faces every single day. How do you forgive that?"
Vanessa cupped his face in her hands. "I don't know. But hiding forever isn't an option either. Cristina's not going to let this go. And even if she does, someone else will get suspicious. The truth always comes out, George. The only question is whether you control how and when."
"I don't know how to tell them."
"Start with one person. Someone you trust."
"I don't trust anyone but you."
"That's not true. You trust Meredith. You trust Bailey, even if she doesn't remember you yet. You trust Cristina, or you wouldn't be this torn up about lying to her." Vanessa's thumbs brushed across his cheekbones. "Pick one. Tell them. See what happens."
"And if they hate me?"
"Then at least you'll know. And you can stop torturing yourself with what-ifs."
George closed his eyes. Took a breath. Let it out slowly.
"Not yet," he said. "I need more time."
"How much time?"
"I don't know. But soon. I promise. Soon."
Vanessa kissed his forehead. "Okay. But George? Don't wait until the decision gets made for you. That's how people get hurt."
She left him alone with his thoughts and his fear and the growing certainty that the life he'd built on lies was about to collapse around him.
And there was nothing he could do to stop it.
Joe's Bar was crowded when George arrived at eight PM. He'd promised Meredith he'd come, and George O'Malley had never been good at breaking promises.
Even when he probably should.
Meredith waved him over to a table in the back where she sat with Cristina, Alex, and a few residents George didn't know. There was an empty chair next to Meredith.
"You came!" Meredith's smile was bright, genuine. "I was betting Cristina that you'd bail."
"I never bet against my own predictions," Cristina said, not looking up from her drink. "Matthews doesn't seem like the bailing type."
George sat down, acutely aware of Cristina's eyes on him. "What are we drinking?"
"Tequila for bad days, beer for normal days, water for when we're on call." Meredith pushed a beer toward him. "You're off tomorrow, right? So beer."
The conversation flowed around him—hospital gossip, surgical war stories, complaints about attendings who weren't present. George nursed his beer and tried to look like he belonged.
"So Matthews," Alex said, leaning back in his chair. "You got a specialty you miss from Hopkins? Something Seattle Grace doesn't do as well?"
"Not really. Every hospital has strengths."
"Diplomatic answer. I'm asking what you actually think."
George considered. "Hopkins had better funding for research. Seattle Grace has better people."
Meredith raised her glass. "I'll drink to that."
"Better people meaning what?" Cristina asked, still watching him.
"Meaning everyone here seems to actually care. About patients, about each other, about the work." George met Cristina's eyes. "At Hopkins, it was competitive. Cutthroat. Here, it feels like a team."
"We've lost a lot of team members," Meredith said quietly. "Maybe that's why we hold onto each other harder."
An uncomfortable silence fell over the table.
"George O'Malley," one of the residents said suddenly—a young woman George didn't recognize. "That's who you remind me of, Dr. Matthews. The way you talk about patients."
George's beer glass froze halfway to his mouth.
"You knew George?" Meredith asked the resident.
"No, I started after he died. But everyone talks about him. The resident who died a hero, saved a stranger, super compassionate with patients." The resident looked at George. "That's you. The compassionate attending who treats patients like people."
"I didn't know him," George managed. "But thank you for the comparison."
"It's a good comparison," Meredith said, her voice soft. "George was one of the best people I've ever known."
Cristina stood abruptly. "I need another drink. Matthews, help me carry them."
It wasn't a request.
George followed her to the bar, where Cristina ordered another round and then turned to face him.
"How long are you going to keep this up?" she asked.
"I don't know what you mean."
"Yes, you do. You move like him, talk like him, care like him. Everyone sees it except everyone's too caught up in their grief to actually look at you and wonder why a stranger has a dead man's mannerisms."
"Cristina—"
"I'm not done." She stepped closer, her voice dropping. "I don't know who you are, Matthews. I don't know why you're here or what you're hiding. But I know this: you're going to break Meredith's heart when the truth comes out. She's already bonding with you because you remind her of George. When she finds out you've been lying to her—about whatever this is—it's going to destroy her."
"I don't want to hurt her."
"Then stop lying."
"It's not that simple."
"It never is." Cristina grabbed the drinks. "But here's the thing, Matthews. I protect my people. Meredith, Bailey, this hospital—they're mine. And if you hurt them, I will end your career. I don't care who you are or what your reasons are. Understood?"
"Understood."
"Good." She handed him half the drinks. "Now come on. We're going to go back to that table and you're going to keep pretending to be someone you're not, and I'm going to keep pretending I don't see right through you. But this conversation isn't over. Not even close."
They returned to the table. George sat next to Meredith and tried to be present, to engage, to be the person they thought he was.
But all he could think about was Cristina's warning.
You're going to break Meredith's heart.
Yeah.
He probably was.
And there was nothing he could do to stop it.
patreon.com/Twilightsky588 - 10 advanced chapters