Chapter 21: Familiar Ground
Seattle greeted us with gray skies and the particular chill of Pacific Northwest autumn.
The police department was familiar—same building, same entrance, same conference room we'd used during the Collector case. Detective Mills was waiting when we arrived, looking older than he should for the time that had passed.
"BAU." He shook Hotch's hand, then mine. "Good to have you back, Agent Mercer. Though I wish it was under better circumstances."
"So do we."
The case files spread across the conference table told a story of escalating psychological violence. Three families, sixteen victims total, all of them shattered by information they'd never wanted exposed.
"The Hendersons were first," Mills explained, pointing to photos of a middle-aged couple and their teenage children. "Home invasion on October 3rd. The unsub spent six hours telling them about Martin Henderson's gambling debts—debts his wife didn't know about. When he left, the family was intact physically. Three days later, they filed for divorce."
"The second family?" Gideon asked.
"The Patels. October 10th. Same pattern—restraint, psychological torture, release. This time, the unsub revealed that their college-age daughter had been paying tuition by working as a cam girl. The parents didn't know. The daughter attempted suicide two days after the attack."
"She survived?" Elle's voice was tight.
"Barely. She's in psychiatric care now." Mills moved to the third family. "The Thompsons. October 17th. The unsub revealed an affair between the wife and her husband's brother. Told the children in detail. The family is currently in three different locations, refusing to speak to each other."
The room fell silent.
[PATTERN ANALYSIS: ACTIVE]
[UNSUB PROFILE: MISSION-ORIENTED — BELIEVES IN "EXPOSING TRUTH"]
[ESCALATION RISK: HIGH — TERRORIZING WILL BECOME KILLING]
[FOCUS: -5]
The system confirmed what I already suspected. This unsub wasn't going to stop at psychological destruction. Sooner or later, a family would resist, or he'd decide that death was a more permanent form of truth-telling.
How much time do we have?
"The intervals are consistent," Reid observed. "Roughly one week between attacks. If the pattern holds, he'll strike again within the next few days."
"Then we need to find him before that happens," Hotch said. "What do we know about victim selection?"
"That's where it gets interesting." I pulled up the TownConnect data Garcia had sent. "All three families were active users of this neighborhood communication app. They posted regularly—updates about their lives, their children, their problems."
"He's researching them through the app," Morgan said. "Building profiles before he strikes."
"More than that." I pointed to specific posts from each family. "Look at the timing. Each family shared something particularly vulnerable in the weeks before their attack. Henderson posted about financial stress. Patel mentioned her daughter's 'expensive' college experience. Thompson made a vague comment about marital problems."
"He's selecting them based on what they reveal," Elle said. "Looking for families with secrets worth exposing."
"Which means he's monitoring the platform constantly," Gideon added. "Waiting for the right targets to identify themselves."
Garcia's voice crackled through the speaker—she'd stayed on the line, working remotely.
"I've been digging into TownConnect user data. The three families don't share any mutual connections, but they do share one thing: all three had their accounts viewed by the same anonymous profile in the weeks before their attacks."
"Anonymous?" Hotch asked.
"The profile was created with a fake name and burner email. No posts, no activity except viewing other users' pages. But here's the kicker—the profile was deleted yesterday."
"He knows we're coming," Morgan said.
"Or he's planning to move and doesn't want loose ends." I studied the data on my laptop. "Garcia, can you trace who else this profile viewed? Other families he might be researching?"
"Way ahead of you, handsome. There are forty-seven families in the Seattle area whose TownConnect profiles were viewed by this account. I'm cross-referencing now to see which ones shared vulnerable information recently."
"Narrow it down," Hotch ordered. "We need likely targets before he strikes again."
"On it."
The briefing continued—geographic profiling, behavioral analysis, the standard toolkit of the BAU. I contributed where I could, steering the investigation toward angles I knew would pay off without revealing how I knew.
The digital stalking angle will lead to suspects. Garcia will find the deleted accounts. We'll narrow from there.
But we're racing the clock.
Reid was sketching timelines on a whiteboard, mapping the unsub's movements. "The attacks occur at night—between 8 PM and 2 AM. He's selecting times when families are home together but isolated. No visitors, no interruptions."
"Suggests employment with a traditional schedule," Gideon observed. "Someone who works days and has evenings free."
"Or someone who's unemployed and has complete freedom," Elle countered. "The level of research required suggests a lot of time investment."
"Both possibilities." Hotch turned to Mills. "What can you tell us about the physical descriptions?"
"All three families describe the same man—medium height, medium build, wearing dark clothing and a ski mask. Gloves at all times, so no fingerprints. Professional about forensics, but emotional about his mission."
"Emotional how?"
"He gets agitated when families resist the information. One victim tried to argue that his affair wasn't as bad as the unsub made it sound. The unsub reportedly became furious—screaming about 'accepting the truth' and 'consequences for lies.'"
[PSYCHOLOGICAL PROFILE UPDATE]
[TRIGGER: DENIAL OF REVEALED INFORMATION]
[RISK FACTOR: AGGRESSION WHEN CHALLENGED]
[NOTE: IF VICTIM PHYSICALLY RESISTS, LETHAL RESPONSE PROBABLE]
That's the escalation point. A family that fights back.
"He sees himself as a truth-teller," I said. "Someone who believes he's performing a service by exposing lies. But his investment in that identity makes him volatile. If a family challenges his narrative—refuses to accept the 'truth' he's delivering—"
"He could turn violent," Morgan finished.
"More than violent. He could decide that some truths need to be permanent."
The room absorbed the implications.
"Then we need to find him before that happens," Hotch said. "Reid, continue the geographic profile. Morgan, Elle—interview the families. See if there's anything they haven't told local law enforcement. Mercer, work with Garcia on the digital angle. Gideon, with me—we need to brief the Seattle field office."
The team dispersed into controlled chaos.
I found a quiet corner and called Garcia directly.
"Talk to me about the user profiles," I said. "The forty-seven families the anonymous account viewed—how many shared vulnerable information in the last month?"
"I'm narrowing now. Filtering for posts about financial problems, relationship issues, family conflicts..." Keys clicked rapidly. "Okay, that brings it down to twenty-three."
"Can you check which of those twenty-three also had their accounts viewed multiple times? If he's selecting targets, he'd want to confirm before striking."
"Smart thinking." More clicking. "That narrows it to... nine families. Nine potential targets."
"Cross-reference with the geographic profile Reid's building. The unsub's comfort zone should be within a certain radius of all three attack sites."
"Doing it now." A pause. "We're down to five families. Five potential targets in his likely operating area."
"Can you pull their profiles? See which ones posted the most vulnerable information?"
"Already looking." Garcia's voice shifted—the tone she got when something clicked. "Oh. Oh, this is bad."
"What?"
"One of the families—the Donovans—posted last week about their 'marriage troubles.' Vague, but enough to suggest serious problems. And their account was viewed by our anonymous profile four times in the past two weeks."
"They're next."
"That's what I'm thinking." More typing. "I'm sending you the address. And Ethan? This family has two kids. Eight and ten years old."
My chest tightened.
Kids. Always kids.
"Get this to Hotch. We need to reach out to the Donovans—warn them, put them under protection, use them to set a trap. Whatever works."
"On it."
I hung up and started moving.
Elle fell into step beside me in the hallway—close enough to talk, far enough to look professional.
"Garcia found something?"
"Likely next target. Family of four, two young children. We need to move fast."
"What do you need?"
"Help convincing Hotch that protective custody isn't enough. If we warn the Donovans and pull them out, the unsub moves to another target. But if we use them as bait—"
"We catch him before he can strike again." Elle's jaw tightened. "Risky. Using a family with kids as bait."
"I know. But if we don't, another family gets destroyed. Maybe worse."
She was quiet for a moment.
"Let's brief Hotch. Make the case."
We walked toward the command center together—professional distance maintained, but moving in the same direction.
The Donovans don't know it yet, but they're about to become the center of a very dangerous game.
Let's make sure they survive it.
Garcia's voice crackled through my earpiece as I reached the command center door.
"I've got more. The anonymous profile—I traced the IP address through three different VPN services. Took some creative work, but I found the source."
"Where?"
"A public library in Beacon Hill. Free WiFi, no ID required. But the library has security cameras."
"Can you get the footage?"
"Already requested. If our guy used that library's WiFi, we'll have his face within the hour."
"Good work, Garcia."
"I know. Now go catch him."
I pushed through the door.
Hotch looked up from a map spread across the table.
"Garcia found a likely target," I said. "And possibly a lead on the unsub's location. We're running out of time."
The case was accelerating.
And somewhere in Seattle, a family with two children didn't know they'd already been selected.
To supporting Me in Pateron .
with exclusive access to more chapters (based on tiers more chapters for each tiers) on my Patreon, you get more chapters if you ask for more (in few days), plus new fanfic every week! Your support starting at just $6/month helps me keep crafting the stories you love across epic universes like [ In The Witcher With Avatar Powers,In The Vikings With Deja Vu System,Stranger Things Demogorgon Tamer ...].
By joining, you're not just getting more chapters—you're helping me bring new worlds, twists, and adventures to life. Every pledge makes a huge difference!
👉 Join now at patreon.com/TheFinex5 and start reading today!