Chapter 23: The Father's Investigation
[Bobby Singer's Salvage Yard, South Dakota — November 8, 2005, Afternoon]
Bobby's house smelled like old books and gun oil and the particular kind of dust that accumulated in places where knowledge was valued more than cleanliness. The salvage yard sprawled around it like a metal forest, rusted cars stacked three high, creating a labyrinth only Bobby could navigate with confidence.
"Heard you had some excitement in Chicago," Bobby said, pouring coffee that looked thick enough to strip paint. "Demons, shadow things, John getting himself captured."
"Understatement." Dean accepted the coffee, took a sip, grimaced. "Is John here?"
Bobby nodded toward the door that led to his library. "Been in there for three days. Hasn't slept much. Barely eats." He shot Ethan a look that contained equal parts curiosity and concern. "He's researching you."
"I figured."
"You okay with that?"
Ethan shrugged. "If I were in his position, I'd do the same thing. Better he finds out from books than from speculation."
The library door opened before Bobby could respond. John Winchester emerged, looking like a man who'd spent three days wrestling with information that didn't want to be understood. His eyes were bloodshot, his jaw stubbled, his clothes rumpled from sleeping in chairs.
In his hands, he carried a stack of printouts covered in handwritten notes.
"You," he said, pointing at Ethan. "We need to talk."
They gathered in Bobby's living room—the six-person space that served as a war room for hunters passing through. John spread his research across the coffee table: photocopied manuscripts, translated texts, printouts from websites Ethan suspected most people didn't know existed.
"Spirits of Vengeance," John said. "Ghost Riders. The Pale Horsemen. Different names, different cultures, same basic concept." He tapped a page showing medieval woodcuts. "Pre-Christian texts talk about judgment entities—things that existed before Hell, before demons, before the Fall. God's executioners for the damned."
Ethan studied the images. A flaming skeleton on horseback, chains wrapped around its arms. A woman with fire for hair, standing over burning sinners. A man whose eyes blazed with righteous fury, judging souls in a language older than words.
"This is what you carry," John continued. "Something older than Lucifer. Older than the angels, some texts claim. It was created to punish the guilty before Hell existed to receive them."
"I didn't know any of this," Ethan said quietly. And he didn't—not the details, not the scope of it. The show had never gone deep into the Spirit's origins.
"Neither did I, until three days ago." John's gaze was sharp, assessing. "But here's the question that kept me up nights: why did it choose YOU?"
The room went quiet. Dean and Sam exchanged looks. Bobby refilled his coffee cup with deliberate slowness, clearly content to let this conversation play out.
"I died saving children," Ethan said. "At least, I think I did—the memories are fragmented, unclear. I spent my life hunting people who hurt innocents: human traffickers, abusers, predators. When the Spirit came, it... recognized something in me. A purpose that matched its own."
"You think you know why it chose you."
"I think I know why it tolerates me. What it sees in me that makes the partnership work." Ethan met John's eyes. "I don't know why it awakened now, after centuries dormant. I don't know what it wants beyond judgment. And I don't know what happens if I fail to meet its expectations."
John studied him for a long moment. Ethan could see the calculations happening behind his eyes—threat assessment, risk evaluation, the cold calculus of a man who'd spent two decades learning to survive in a world where trust got people killed.
"You're not lying," John said finally.
"I don't know how to lie about something I don't understand."
"That's what makes you dangerous." John gathered his research, straightening pages with hands that showed the calluses of long practice. "You're carrying a weapon you can't fully control, bonded to an entity with goals you can't comprehend. Most people in your position would be a liability—a time bomb waiting to go off."
"Most people aren't me."
"No. They're not." John's expression shifted—not warming exactly, but acknowledging something he hadn't been willing to see before. "Bobby says you're useful. My boys say you've saved their lives. Ellen Harvelle says you made her a promise about accountability."
"If I become a threat, I expect to be treated like one."
"Good." John nodded once. "Because I'm going to hold you to that. I don't trust you—I probably never will. But I'll work with you. For now. Until you give me a reason to stop."
Dean let out a breath he'd clearly been holding. "So we're good? No more standoffs, no more interrogations?"
"We're functional," John said. "Good comes later. Maybe."
Ethan accepted this. John Winchester wasn't a man who offered friendship easily—his trust had to be earned through action, through consistency, through proving that the monster inside Ethan's chest served something other than its own hunger.
That would take time. Ethan was willing to invest it.
Bobby stood, crossing to the cabinet where he kept the good whiskey. "Family meetings are exhausting. Drink up."
He poured glasses for everyone—even Sam, who usually declined. John accepted his with something that might have been a smile.
"To strange alliances," Bobby said, raising his glass.
"To strange alliances," the others echoed.
The whiskey burned going down, warm and familiar. Ethan found himself relaxing for the first time in days, the tension of Chicago and its aftermath finally beginning to fade.
John left the next morning, disappearing into the predawn darkness with a nod to his sons and a final assessment of Ethan that carried neither hostility nor warmth. He had leads to follow, demons to track, answers to find. His hunt was solitary by necessity and choice.
Dean watched the truck's taillights fade into the South Dakota morning. "He likes you."
"He threatened to kill me. Twice."
"Yeah. That's improvement." Dean's grin was tired but genuine. "First time we brought someone home who wasn't human, he shot first and asked questions never. The fact that you got questions at all means he's considering you."
Sam emerged from Bobby's house, laptop under one arm, expression thoughtful. "I've been going through Bobby's network. There's a case that might need attention—electrical disturbances in Nebraska, something targeting a construction site. Fits the profile of a raw head."
"What's a raw head?" Ethan asked.
"Irish folklore. Protective spirits that guard places from intruders, but if they're corrupted or awakened wrong, they become dangerous. This one's been killing workers who get too close to something buried on the property."
"Sounds straightforward."
"They always do." Sam's expression suggested he didn't believe that any more than Ethan did. "We should check it out. Bobby's going to keep researching the Spirit of Vengeance stuff, see if he can find anything John missed."
Dean was already walking toward the Impala. "Road trip. I call shotgun."
"You're driving, Dean. You can't call shotgun."
"I call it anyway."
Ethan grabbed his truck keys. Three weeks with the Winchesters had taught him their rhythms—the banter that masked deeper bonds, the arguments that never meant anything, the way they checked on each other without seeming to.
He was starting to fit into that rhythm. Starting to belong.
The Spirit hummed in his chest, content for now, waiting for the next opportunity to judge.
Author's Note / Promotion:
Your Reviews and Power Stones are the best way to show support. They help me know what you're enjoying and bring in new readers!
You don't have to. Get instant access to more content by supporting me on Patreon. I have three options so you can pick how far ahead you want to be:
🪙 Silver Tier ($6): Read 10 chapters ahead of the public site.
👑 Gold Tier ($9): Get 15-20 chapters ahead of the public site.
💎 Platinum Tier ($15): The ultimate experience. Get new chapters the second I finish them . No waiting for weekly drops, just pure, instant access.
Your support helps me write more .
👉 Find it all at patreon.com/fanficwriter1