Chrono drew a deep breath, closing his eyes. He inhaled slowly through his nose, then exhaled through his mouth. When he opened his eyes again, they were steady.
"May." He stepped closer to her. "I've made my decision."
"And my decision is… this."
Will this really be the most selfless thing I'll do?
Am I really doing this for someone else?
Is this… the right thing to do?
Is this really okay?
After everything Talia has done for me?
After everything she said to me?
After seeing her dying message?
…
I don't know.
Either way… this is the only way I can atone.
For everything I've done wrong.
Chrono placed a hand firmly over his chest. His gaze was focused yet unsteady, and his chest rose and fell with uneven breaths. "I will… I will continue this challenge."
May's angered expression softened. Her lips curled into a wide, cunning smile. She had won.
"Good. That's what I like to hear. You're coming to your senses, Zeph."
She sighed and gave a light shrug. "A shame though. I had a few more ideas in mind to 'convince' you."
"No matter what…" Chrono paused, voice low but firm. "…I will continue this challenge."
May raised a brow. "Continue…? A weird way to phrase it." She scoffed. "But of course, I'm not going to ask you to explain yourself. I can't stand being around you anymore."
Chrono didn't reply. He lowered his hand from his chest and let out a heavy, exhausted sigh.
"Nothing else to say, huh? So you can shut your mouth." She turned her back on him. "Well, my job here is done. I don't want to see you again for a while."
As May made her way toward the kitchen window, seemingly prepared to leave, she stopped and turned back to face him.
"Oh right. I forgot one thing." She folded her arms.
"You forgot something?"
"Yeah, that's right. I had a question for you." She pressed one hand against her forehead. "But I never expected you to be this pathetic, so I forgot while I was trying to convince you."
"But… I remember now. The question I had for you."
Another pause settled over the room. Chrono didn't speak. He simply waited, his gaze faintly uneasy.
May clicked her tongue. "The hell? Did you turn into a husk?" She let out a frustrated groan. "Whatever. I'll just get this over with."
She lowered her hand from her forehead and pointed directly at him. "How many laws do you think you've triggered?"
"How many laws I've triggered?" Chrono repeated, his voice uncertain.
It… it has to be two, right?
Veritas Law and Nocturne's Law.
Just those two.
Did I trigger one I'm unaware of?
No… no way.
What could I have done to trigger another law?
But… I'm really unsure.
May asked a question like this earlier.
About the penalty for failing the challenge altogether.
My answer was wrong.
Or rather… incomplete.
Could it be something similar here?
May put a thumb down, mimicking the sharp sound of an incorrect buzzer. "Wroooong!"
I didn't even say anything!
Chrono's eyes widened. "Huh!? I've only triggered two laws."
May wagged her finger. "Nope! You definitely triggered at least one more."
"Quit screwing around with me…"
"Well, I can't really blame you for not knowing. It isn't fully triggered from your actions alone."
"So you're saying something else other than me can trigger it?"
May placed a finger against her lip. "Ehhh… something like that. I'll give you a half mark."
Chrono gritted his teeth. "You're lying. How can a law not be fully triggered by the player? That doesn't make sense."
"Well, Veritas Law isn't fully triggered by you, is it?"
Chrono fell silent, fists clenching at his sides.
"But I will admit that this one functions a bit differently than Veritas. There's even a chance it can be triggered without your involvement. What a scary law…"
"Oh, and also—I won't be telling you what it is. Figure that out on your own. I've given you enough information."
"Why are you even telling me this?"
May rolled her eyes. "You asked me the same thing when I explained Veritas Law. Whatever I said then still stands."
She turned away again and walked back toward the kitchen window, then stopped once more.
She turned her head just enough for him to see part of her face. "This is a battle for our lives, Zeph. Remember that."
She opened the window and hopped onto the edge.
A battle for our lives…?
"May!" Chrono called out.
She didn't turn around, but she paused, waiting.
"What loop did this law get triggered?"
May was quiet for a moment. "Didn't I tell you? You have to figure everything else out yourself. If you look at the timeline it should be pretty obvious. Don't ask me another stupid question like that again."
She hopped out and disappeared into the morning breeze.
Chrono stared at the open window longer than he should have. His eyes were wide. He covered his mouth as her words fully registered, a bead of sweat sliding down his temple.
"Did she really trigger another law…? A third one I'm unaware of?" he asked himself aloud, tapping a finger against his cheek.
She could be lying… but…
This isn't the first time she's done this.
She told me about Veritas Law…
And Nocturne's Law.
Although she holds back information, she does tell me about these laws.
And they aren't lies either.
She has a very strange way of going about this.
That leads me to believe she isn't lying about this, based on what I know so far.
That does mean if it was triggered in the loop Talia died, then she triggered two laws in a single loop.
Damn it…
Just how far ahead of me is she…?
Chrono lowered his hand, walked to the open window, and closed it slowly.
But that's the question, isn't it?
What loop was it even triggered?
I do want to say it was triggered in the Talia loop, but…
What she said bothers me.
That it can even be triggered without my involvement.
Does that mean anyone can trigger it?
Like an average person?
Or anyone bound to this challenge?
Damn it…
She left it vague on purpose.
But she wants me to figure this out. That's why she gave me a hint.
She's babying me…
Chrono walked over to the counter, leaned his back against it, and folded his arms.
Okay…
I can figure this out.
It'd be a problem if I didn't.
Using what May said, what I already know, and the past loops, I think I can work it out.
Alright.
First I need to decide what she meant by "can be triggered without your involvement," and who exactly she's referring to.
If it can be triggered by anyone, then it'd be nearly impossible to single out.
There are so many people doing different things.
The chance of finding out which of those actions caused the law to trigger is pretty low.
But if anyone can trigger the law, then what does that mean?
…
Chrono's eyes widened. He had realized something.
Is that it?
What May said.
"There's even a chance it can be triggered without your involvement."
A chance…
Does that mean I triggered it this time, but there's a possibility that someone else could trigger it instead?
Still…
That doesn't answer how regular people could trigger the law.
Hold on…
Can regular people even influence the loop… directly?
Because if the laws are bound to the challenge, which is loop-bound, then people not bound to the challenge shouldn't be able to influence it directly.
Kinda like how I'm the only one who can trigger Nocturne's Law.
And how Veritas can't be triggered without my influence.
Then again…
May did say this one functions differently.
But…
I can't just ignore this.
I think I can safely say regular people can't trigger any laws.
So then I have to focus on the people who are—or were—bound to the loop.
Which would be me, May, Talia, the thousand people I have to convince… and maybe March.
Based on this, I think it's safe to say the law was triggered in Talia's loop.
Since May herself can't directly trigger the law, and Talia and March weren't variables at that time.
As for me now…
Based on what she said, I played a part in triggering the law, but it wasn't fully done by me alone.
Nothing I did in the loop I fought May matches up with triggering a new law.
I think I can say it happened in the loop after that.
Now then…
I need to recall the events of that loop.
It started normally. I spoke with Xander, Talia, and Iris.
Then May suddenly appeared in my class, and a desk appeared beside mine.
I never saw her at school after that, and the day went on as normal.
After school I met up with Talia, and we headed to the café.
There I explained the details of Plan B and agreed to team up with her for sports day.
Then May appeared and forced me to trigger Veritas, and abruptly left afterward.
I started explaining everything… well, most of what I knew about the loops, and possible theories.
We walked around a little and ran into Iris and March.
Then the entire confrontation happened… and Talia died as a result.
After that I heard a hum and started running, where I encountered the piles of corpses.
I headed home, which is where I saw the rotting little girl.
She forced me toward my parents' room.
I escaped through the window and ran toward the beach, intending to kill myself.
Then fog surrounded me. I saw the girl again… and died.
Or maybe it hit 12:00?
I'm not sure.
Chrono placed a hand on his chin, sinking deeper into thought.
But this loop has been pretty weird.
Especially around the time May appeared, and toward the end.
The corpses. The rotting girl.
The hum and the fog.
I couldn't wrap my head around what caused all four of those, but I think I have an idea now.
This has to be the result of the law being triggered.
Somehow, everyone being killed is a consequence of this law.
Or maybe it just comes with the law itself?
But that creates another question.
What exactly is that girl?
I didn't really think about it before, but is she an enforcer of the law?
May said they were shadow soldiers.
Nocturne and Veritas looked like armor covered in shadow.
But she didn't.
So why would those two appear like that, and she didn't?
…
Maybe she isn't a shadow soldier, or an enforcer at all.
That isn't important right now.
I think it's safe to assume the corpses and the fog are a result of the law.
Now then—I need to look at the events in that loop and what could have caused it.
It's also safe to assume anything before the fight with March isn't the cause. The activation timing would be way off.
So… I need to look at the events of the fight itself.
And I think I know what it is.
It has to be March's death.
He himself said he would deny the rules the figure set in place.
And he did.
Realistically, there should have been no way he was still alive after Nocturne's Law triggered.
And yet…
He was.
He knew what he was doing.
He knew his actions would be defying the rules.
If he was so sure it would work…
Then… it wasn't in the moment.
It was planned.
A gamble, but still planned.
I don't know if May or March came up with it, but it's insane to think about.
Creating a plan to defy the very rules.
A plan to defy the rules…
Chrono started tapping a finger against his cheek and his foot against the floor.
There has to be a reason they planned to defy the rules.
Because there isn't really a reason for them to do so otherwise.
Unless, of course, a law can only be triggered as a result of breaking the rules.
That would make sense.
But then again…
Did March really have a choice?
If he didn't do that, he'd die.
Is it really possible to plan out that entire situation up until that point?
…
Chrono lowered his hand from his face, slid both hands into his pockets, and stopped tapping his foot.
Where do I go from here?
March's death could have caused the law to trigger.
And there's a chance it was planned.
But could March's death really be the cause of all those bodies?
…
Alright.
I need to figure out why March's death could've triggered the law.
And from that, I think I'll have everything answered.
Right now I have the apparent cause and the effect, but not the "why."
Where do I even start with this?
…
Okay. I think I've got it.
I need to look at how he actually died.
I took a paper from the book and pressed it against his skin.
It should've killed him because of Nocturne's Law—and it did.
But he reversed it with a veil.
The main problem here is him reversing his death.
Nocturne's Law says "anything that can die will die."
And yet something that can die… didn't stay dead when the law was triggered.
But that's a problem with Nocturne's Law, not another one.
Or… is it…?
Damn it…
I don't know…
Nocturne's Law…
How does it play a part in this?
How do Nocturne's Law and March's death trigger another law?
No…
Not how, but why?
That's what I need to answer.
Nocturne's Law…
And…
March's death…
Nocturne's Law…
…Nocturne's Law…
Nocturne's Law…?
Chrono paused. Then his eyes shot wide open. He had noticed something critical.
That's it!
Nocturne's Law!
The answer is in what happens when it gets triggered.
First, it kills the person who comes into contact with a part of the book that isn't me.
And it also erases their existence…
That's it…
That's where the problem lies…
March's existence should've been erased after he died.
Meaning every trace of his actions should have been removed from reality.
And yet…
Iris and Talia were still dead.
That's… a contradiction…
Nocturne's Law should erase the actions of someone who died to the law.
And yet the actions of someone the universe no longer perceives as real still remain.
That…
That doesn't make any sense.
How can that even be possible?
…
But what if that's the issue?
This creates a situation that's quite literally impossible.
It doesn't make sense because it shouldn't be able to happen.
And that's when the law steps in… or rather, gets triggered.
It needed to fix this contradiction.
I'm not sure how, or if the piles of corpses can fully explain it, but…
This surely has to be the answer.
The law corrects contradictions in the universe—and that's why it can be triggered by someone other than me.
But to even notice something like this is…
Insane…
May knew all of this and orchestrated a situation where something impossible became possible, forcing this law to be triggered.
What the hell…?
Is this… is this what she wanted me to realize?
She wanted to let me know what I'm up against?
…
That doesn't matter right now.
What does matter is that I think I've figured out how this law works.
What I still don't understand is why the rotting girl exists, and the bodies.
For now I'll just treat them as a result of the law being triggered.
I don't have enough information about the "why" yet.
Chrono let out a long sigh, pushed off the counter, and made his way to the stairs. He began climbing them slowly.
Could I really have figured out something like this?
Is my answer really right?
There's no way of knowing yet.
But…
I'm just unsure someone like me could figure this out.
I can't do anything right.
So how…?
How could I…?
He stopped near the top of the staircase. His jaw tightened. His face went pale.
"Just a little longer… I need to hold out," he said to himself, voice uncertain.
I need to figure out what to do next.
The next stage of this challenge.
I can't rely on Talia… I never should've.
I'm in this alone, and I always will be.
Involving someone else will always do more harm than good.
So… from this point on…
I'll be doing everything alone.
Chrono let out another sigh, trying to calm himself. Some unease still remained on his face.
I need a way to identify the people I need to convince.
Then I need to gather them in one area.
I also have to take into account the events that happen during the day and list them out.
I'll probably have to ditch the blackmail idea, since I have no way to find dirt on a thousand people in only ten loops.
I'd be spending too much time on that.
Although…
I do have something in mind.
But it does require me to break the rule of preventing anyone from looping with me.
Can I force someone to loop?
That's what I want to find out.
He continued walking and made his way to the bathroom. He stood in front of the door, one hand on his chin as he stared at it blankly.
I need a way to access student records.
I, of course, don't know a thousand people.
I'm a bit iffy about using a thousand random people from school, since there's a chance the challenges are connected.
And then a thousand wouldn't just be a random number.
So I need a controlled group of a thousand people.
The problem is how I'm even going to get access to the records.
They're in the main office, sure, but it'd be way too difficult to get in there.
There has to be an easier way.
…
…
…
…
The student council?
They should have some records, right?
If so, then getting the records from there would be way easier.
But…
Iris is part of the student council.
If she's there, then…
I don't think I could hold back my emotions.
I have no choice though.
I have to do this.
I need to do this.
No matter what.
But… will I even be fine after seeing her?
I… I don't know.
I don't know how I'll react.
Chrono let out another sigh—this one shaky and heavy. "A battle for our lives, huh?" He repeated the words May had said to him. There was a long pause as he dwelled on them.
"Alright then… I'll treat it as such."
A battle for our lives.
I will do my best.
And maybe…
Maybe if I do that, I can atone.
I can atone…
For all my sins…
