"No," Marcus answered at the same time.
Ruth smiled despite herself.
Matthew lowered his voice theatrically.
"He follows people around and pretends it is leadership."
"I can hear you."
"That is because you are hovering."
Marcus gave his brother a warning look through the mirror.
Ruth covered her mouth to hide a laugh.
The sound made Marcus turn again.
For a brief second, he looked pleased.
Then Ruth noticed him watching and immediately looked out the window.
His expression fell.
The sight did not escape Matthew.
He turned toward the passing landscape, choosing not to comment.
Grayhaven Bay appeared beyond the trees a few minutes later.
The wide stretch of water glittered beneath the afternoon sun. Boats moved peacefully across the harbor, while a paved walkway followed the edge of the cliff.
It was beautiful.
Ruth stepped out of the car and inhaled the salty air.
Something shifted inside her.
Not a memory.
A feeling.
She had been here before.
She knew it without knowing why.
Marcus watched her carefully.
"You feel it."
It was not a question.
Ruth rubbed her arms.
"I don't know."
"You used to come here whenever you wanted to think."
She glanced at the cliffside path.
"How often?"
"Whenever you were angry with me."
Matthew placed his hands inside his pockets.
"So, regularly."
Ruth laughed.
Marcus did not.
He began walking along the path.
"Come."
It was not an invitation.
It was an instruction.
Ruth looked at Matthew.
He gave her a reassuring nod.
"I'll stay close."
She followed reluctantly.
Marcus talked as they walked.
He pointed toward a bench near the water.
"You sat there the day you told me you were leaving."
Ruth stopped.
"Leaving?"
Marcus turned.
"You had accepted an opportunity abroad."
"Why?"
His expression changed.
Because you had finally grown tired of waiting for me.
He did not say it.
"You wanted a fresh start."
Ruth studied him.
"And you stopped me?"
"Yes."
"Why?"
Marcus stepped closer.
"Because I realized I could not let you go."
The breeze lifted strands of her crimson hair across her face.
For one dangerously quiet moment, neither moved.
Ruth's heart began beating harder.
She did not remember him.
But the way he looked at her made her feel as though he remembered enough for both of them.
Matthew remained several steps away, allowing them space while still watching Ruth's expression.
Marcus gestured toward the path ahead.
"There is more."
Ruth looked at the uneven stone steps leading toward an upper viewing deck.
Her ankle had recovered, but the steps were steep.
Marcus moved first, then turned toward her.
He extended his hand.
"Come."
Ruth stared at it.
His open palm waited between them.
Strong.
Steady.
Certain she would take it.
Marcus's eyes carried the same certainty.
As if her hand had belonged there so often that refusing him had never occurred to him.
Something inside Ruth tightened.
The sound of the waves faded.
Her breathing became shallow.
A cold whisper seemed to crawl through the back of her mind.
Do not trust him.
She took one step back.
Marcus frowned.
"Ruth?"
Her gaze remained fixed on his waiting hand.
"No."
The answer was barely audible.
He lowered his arm only slightly.
"It is only a few steps."
"I can manage."
"The stones are uneven."
"I said I can manage."
His jaw tightened with impatience.
"Why must you argue over everything?"
The question struck her like an accusation.
Her pulse began to race.
Matthew moved forward.
"Marcus."
But Marcus's attention remained fixed on Ruth.
"You trusted me before."
"I don't remember that."
"I am trying to help you remember."
"I don't want your help."
The words sharpened.
Marcus's face darkened.
"You cannot keep running away from your own life."
Ruth's chest constricted.
The bay blurred around her.
Voices surfaced from somewhere deep inside her mind.
Male.
Cold.
Persistent.
He will make you believe him.
Do not let him touch you.
Run.
Marcus extended his hand again.
"Ruth. Come with me."
Her eyes widened.
"No."
"Trust me."
"No!"
She stumbled backward.
Matthew rushed toward her, but Marcus moved first.
"Ruth—"
"Don't touch me!"
Everything stopped.
Marcus froze with his hand still suspended between them.
Ruth pressed one hand against her chest.
Her breathing was now fast and uneven.
"I don't know you."
"I am your husband."
"That does not mean I know you!"
The words echoed against the cliff.
Marcus stared at her.
She continued, tears gathering in her eyes.
"You keep showing me photographs. Videos. Places. You keep telling me what I loved, what I wore, what I said, and what I felt."
"I am trying to give your life back."
"You are trying to force me into someone else's life!"
"It was your life."
"I don't remember it!"
Her voice broke.
Marcus's hand slowly lowered.
Ruth shook her head.
"Every time you come near me, I feel like I'm supposed to remember something. Like I'm disappointing you because I can't."
"You could never disappoint me."
"But I do!"
Her tears finally fell.
"I see it every time you look at me."
Marcus's lips parted, but no words came.
Ruth wrapped her arms around herself.
"When I'm with Matthew, I can breathe."
Matthew's expression changed.
Marcus looked as though the statement had physically struck him.
Ruth barely noticed.
"But with you…"
She looked at him, frightened and helpless.
"I can't breathe around you."
The wind continued moving around them.
The waves continued breaking below.
But Marcus heard nothing.
For three months, he had searched for her.
For three months, he had imagined finding her alive.
Never—not even in his darkest moments—had he imagined that when she finally returned, she would look at him as though he were the danger she needed to escape.
Slowly, Marcus lowered the hand she had refused to take.
His fingers curled inward.
"I'm sorry."
The apology was quiet.
Barely there.
But Ruth heard it.
Matthew stepped beside her.
"Let's go back."
She nodded quickly.
Neither of them noticed the loose gravel beneath her heel.
Ruth turned too fast.
The sole of her shoe slipped across the stones.
Her body lurched sideways toward the edge of the path.
Matthew reached out.
Marcus was faster.
"Ruth!"
His arm wrapped around her waist and pulled her backward before she could fall.
Her body crashed against his chest.
Marcus's other hand struck the stone railing as he used his own weight to shield her.
For one breathless second, Ruth was trapped against him.
His heart pounded violently beneath her palm.
His arm tightened around her waist.
Not possessively.
Desperately.
As though letting go would kill him.
"Are you hurt?"
His voice shook.
Ruth stared up at him.
Fear remained.
But something else moved beneath it.
Confusion.
The man she had just rejected had thrown himself between her and the edge without hesitation.
Marcus realized he was still holding her.
He released her immediately and stepped back.
"I'm sorry."
Again.
This time, for touching her.
Matthew steadied Ruth by her shoulders.
"Are you all right?"
She nodded, although her knees trembled.
Marcus's hand was bleeding where it had struck the rough stone.
Ruth noticed.
"You're hurt."
He glanced at the blood.
"It's nothing."
"It's bleeding."
His eyes returned to her face.
"You aren't."
The words silenced her.
Matthew took out a handkerchief from his pocket and gave it to his brother.
Marcus accepted it without looking away from Ruth.
She moved closer to Matthew.
It was instinctive.
Marcus saw it.
And something inside him finally broke.
"Take her home," he said.
Matthew frowned.
"You're coming with us."
"I'll follow later."
"Marcus—"
"Go."
His commanding voice which sounded like pleading, surprised both of them.
Matthew nodded.
Ruth looked at Marcus one last time.
He stood alone beside the railing, one hand wrapped around the other, blood slowly staining the white handkerchief.
He did not ask her to stay.
He did not tell her to remember.
He simply watched her leave.
And for reasons Ruth could not explain, the sight of his empty hand followed her all the way home.
