Brenna spun the bottle. It landed on Aliza. Catherine sighed in relief as Aliza was expecting the worst head-on. "Sweet Aunt Aliza, you've been spending a lot of time with Mallory. I want to ask do you like her...as a woman?"
"I can answer to that! Yes, she's sexy as hell. If I was a man, I would pound that bitch's ass for treating me like one."
"You know that doesn't stop you from fucking her, right! You can still have sex with her as a woman." Catherine asked.
"I'm using my turn before you make your fantasies about me and Mallory!" The bottle landed on Catherine. "I thought I would be getting Sterling!"
"Keep trying! I'm only enjoying it!"
"Catherine, have you ever kissed a woman?"
"Yeah! I kiss Mom, Brenna and occasionally you. I can't believe you just wasted your turn on this question."
"Damn it! I should have excluded family members!"
"Or you could have just said make out. It's different from a sweet peck on the lips." Sterling was enjoying it too much.
"OK, let's target Sterling! He's having so much fun while we're suffering!" Aliza gathered the girls.
"Oh really! Cathy, it's your turn!" Catherine smirked at Sterling and spun the bottle. It landed on her sister instead of her brother. "Oh, poor Cathy! Are you sad that you didn't get me?"
"I'll get you whenever I want. This is a rare opportunity! Brenna, have you ever had sex with Eva?" Brenna didn't expect it. She was in a situation where she had to answer. She could lie but it wouldn't do any better. Aliza will find out about it.
"We...did!" Brenna covered her face with a pillow.
"I knew it. This is why you always have your doors locked. How could you do that with Sterling's girlfriend?" Catherine pointed her finger at her sister yelling.
"Can we drop this? I didn't know follow-up questions were in the rules." Brenna yanked the bottle and spun it. It barely moved and landed on Sterling.
"That's cheating, sis! You have to make at least a complete rotation!" Sterling said as he leaned in towards the table. Annoyed Brenna spun it again and it landed on Sterling. "Wait, what?"
"Oh, we got him!" Catherine celebrated.
"What's your body count?" Brenna asked this question expecting him not to answer it in front of his little sister and aunt. She was trying to get at least a secret out of him. "Are you chickening out, Sterling? Then lay out your dirty secret..."
"12!"
"Huh?"
"Sorry if I took some time. I was counting in my head."
"Why would you say that in front of Catherine?"
"I don't think it bothers Catherine as much as you think it does. I mean two of them are her friends."
"Wait, slow down! Two...Rebecca too?" Aliza was surprised. She was looking at Sterling confused. Sterling was embarrassed but for good reasons. Now that he knew the girls were alright with putting everything on the table. He had the opportunity to be open. He just needed the right chance. He spun the bottle to use his turn. It landed on Aliza.
His eyes met Brenna's. She nodded in agreement. He then turned his attention to Brenna. "Aliza, what happened to Uncle Drew?" Aliza was waiting for any questions that were sex-related and anything embarrassing but this was the taboo question. She could opt for a secret. "Aliza, Mom's not here. Dad's not here either. You can answer without worrying about them."
"Aliza, please tell us! Where is he?" Brenna joined in.
"Can we step back a little? Since when do we have an uncle?" Catherine who had no idea of Drew asked everyone else. "Are we talking about Lucia's dad? Did he come back?"
"It's not...Lucia's dad! Ophelia and I have a brother. Back when Catherine was three, Drew left with Dad to find himself out in the world. We occasionally get some texts about Drew and Dad. David had these specific restrictions about mentioning them in front of you kids. Ophelia was just following his rules. I thought Drew would come back when Dad did but he was managing his business. That is what Dad said."
"Do you know why Dad didn't want us to know about him?" Sterling asked.
"No follow-up questions, right?" Aliza sighed. "Fine! I don't know the real reason but David and Drew drifted apart after Catherine's 3rd birthday. David was a mess and more controlling after that. They had an issue but none of them wanted to talk about it. Now that you guys are adults, just ask David when he wakes up! Maybe he'll tell you."
A silence filled the room. Catherine's was filled with more questions. She just realised that her siblings knew about something she didn't and all of it had something to do with her birthday. She wanted answers but it wasn't the time. "Can we all forget about the uncle issue and move on with the game? This is not how I imagined today to be. We have a meal to prepare afterwards!"
"Catherine's right! Drew can wait." Brenna signalled Sterling to cool off. He nodded back at her as Aliza spun the bottle.
___________________
Inside a bunker outside the city, some agents were snooping. "I've never seen a bunker like this."
"This is not what I expected when we got the lead." The hideout where Cerberus was kept had been abandoned. Detective Wilson's agents found a lead that led to Hunter's latest location but before their arrival, everyone from that location had already left. While the agents were checking the bunker Wilson arrived.
"Are we too late?" Wilson asked one of his agents.
"If we hadn't postponed the search, we could have caught them yesterday!" The agent replied. "By the way, congratulations on the promotion!"
"Thanks, Agent Watts! What do we have here?"
"Well, we found a weird container!"
"A container?"
They all moved onto a narrow way that led to a room. In the middle of it, there was a container, recently emptied. Wilson approached it and observed it closely. "You alright, Wilson?" The detective looked behind. His boss was there. He approached him and stood next to him. "You seem tense. I can't believe how much this case has led. Your client better pay us for all this effort."
"Hello, boss! Are you here to check on what I'm doing?"
"It's the process after a promotion. I wanted to check if the promotion didn't go over your head."
"Don't worry about it. About the payment, my client has already covered our expenses, boss!"
"Why don't you tell me who it is?"
"He prefers to keep his identity a secret. He doesn't trust anyone. As you can see, his enemy has this many resources. Who knows what he's capable of!" Detective Wilson looked around. Something caught his attention. He moved closer to a table nearby. There was a file that had a picture of Cerberus. He opened it and started reading it.
"What is it, Wilson?" The boss asked.
"We have an explanation for one of my client's requests. They classified this thing as a failed project."
"It's about the dog, right? Can't believe they would hurt a dog!"
"Are you a dog person, boss?"
"They are the best! What's the other file?" He pointed at another file. Wilson looked behind and grabbed. It showed disturbing pictures. He quickly closed it. "I need to call my client!"
"Is it something alarming?"
"I know that my target is the worst of the scum but this, he's the most deranged person to even think of something like this!" Wilson and his colleagues moved out of the place without realising an active camera in that place. It was capturing everything live and showing it on a monitor far away. In front of the monitor, a middle-aged man was eating fries.
"Hunter said level 5 but this is beyond. Oldman needs to step up!" The man then turned and clicked on another button. All the footage taken from the cameras in that bunker got erased after that.
*disgusting eating noises*
________________________
Back at the Johnson's household, the bottle was pointing at Sterling. Aliza rubbed her hands and asked her nephew. "Who was the best in bed among all the women you had slept with?" Aliza wanted to pry more about Sterling's sex life. It was relieving for her to talk freely without any restrictions. "Come on, Sterli-boy! Aunty's waiting!" Sterling didn't show any emotion on his face. The girls assumed that he was stalling to not hurt their feelings. Then a smile formed.
"I'm going to reveal a secret." His reply didn't surprise the girls. They just thought what they assumed was right. Then the bomb was dropped. "The three of you have lost your virginity to the same person. And that person is yours truly!" Sterling was pointing both his thumbs at his chest. The girls were in shock. They all looked at each other with embarrassment mixed with confusion. They all got up from their seat and started pointing at the other two.
"You fucked my baby? He's mine!" Brenna yelled at Aliza.
"How could you fuck your brother?" Aliza yelled at Catherine.
"Hey, he was my birthday gift! What was I supposed to do?"
"You had Sydney Sweeney in your room and you chose him over her?" Aliza stormed on Catherine.
"I didn't choose, I did it with both of them!"
"You bitch! You had a threesome?"
"Girls, stop fighting! Although the Spiderman pointing was enjoyable to watch!" Sterling mentioned it as the girls dropped their arms. "Listen, I love all three of you! Sex is my way of showing it and I'm glad I got to show it by giving something precious to you. Please don't fight, you know how I am."
"Damn it! He always gets his way with the kind words!" Brenna pouted as she crossed her arms turning away and showing off her curves. Aliza just realised how much attractive Brenna was in her shorts. Catherine sighed and approached Sterling.
"Sterling, it was shocking to me at first but I know how much I want Brenna and Aliza to happy as I am when I am with you. We can be careful with a peculiar relationship and have fun with it, right?" She hugged him tightly before he could say anything. "Please take good care of my sister and aunt!"
"You know we can do that together, right?" Sterling breathed on the top of the head of his little sister. It sparked an idea from Aliza.
She looked at Brenna again. This time she couldn't get her eyes off of her. She slowly approached Brenna. "Aliza, what are you doing?" Aliza cupped Brenna's face. She leaned her face back but the lust on Aliza's face didn't back down. "Aliza, I don't know if you should be doing this!"
"Brenna, my sweet little niece, you remind me a lot of this girl I kissed back in my teenage. You two are so so alike!" She brought her into a kiss. Brenna was hesitant at first contact but slowly her eyelids started to close, and she kissed her back. Aliza removed her hand from her face and grabbed Brenna's ass. They both dropped together on the couch. Sterling and Catherine who was resting her head on her brother's chest were watching this like proud parents.
"Is this what you were expecting when you changed the rules of the game?"
"My imagination had my dick between your legs plus that!"
"So, you and mom, did you two..?"
"Nope! You three are the only family members I've been with sexually!"
"It would be cool if you seduce Lucia. Maybe she'll be nice if she gets a dick inside her!"
"I love how cunning you are. I hope she comes back!"
"Should we join them?"
"Oh, with pleasure!" Catherine walked up to the couch. Before Sterling could move, he got a text.
"Girls, I'm really sorry about this but we have to move. Mom and Mallory are almost done." Disappointed girls paused what they were about to do and moved on to pleasing Ophelia.
"Sterling, you better fuck Ophelia one day!" Aliza slapped his ass as she made her way to the kitchen.
"Why do you all assume I have an interest in her? She's my mother."
"If you get her, I can get her too! It's easy to seduce her when she feels guilty!" Aliza started working in the kitchen.
"And you two are cool with it?"
"I don't care you fuck. As long as I get my share of you and that big guy!" Catherine caressed his crouch and moved on. Before Sterling could go on, Brenna grabbed him by his wrist and dragged him away from the other two's earshot.
____________________
"Hey, what are you doing, Brenna?" Sterling was concerned about his sister's behaviour. "Are you not okay with this?"
"I'm okay with it. It feels right for me. And that's what I'm worried about. Sterling, are we becoming like him? Sex-obsessed people who wouldn't think sleeping with family isn't wrong."
"Babe, we're not hurting anyone! He did!"
"I know that. What if we inherited his sense of what's right and wrong? I'm alright being sexual around with Catherine but Catherine was including Ophelia earlier. So did Aliza. She's not an active participant in this shenanigans but you're already talking about it."
"You know they were just throwing ideas, right? I wouldn't sleep with Mom unless she wants me to!"
"Sterling, we're not that different from him."
"He was drugging our food. Mallory even fell for it. It's a good thing she found me before he did. And that night when you were alone, she made you scared to death. Neither of us is capable of doing that to our loved ones."
"But..."
"We're not Hunter. The only thing preventing him from raping you girls is his thrill for the rivalry he has with me. He wants to embarrass me by taking away you girls with his tricks as an act of revenge on Dad. You and I want to show affection." Brenna slowly walked up to Sterling and rested her head on his shoulder. "Babe, when you kissed Aliza earlier, I only saw how much you liked her as a woman and a person. If it was Hunter, he would only see her as a trophy. You know that deep down. We're not monsters like Hunter. We're lovers like the ones who came before Hunter or Grandma Annabelle for instance. You remember what mom used to say about her."
"She's the best mother in this entire world. She's the most caring person." Brenna said as she looked at her brother directly in his eyes. The reflection of her weeping face showed her she was different from her grandfather.
"One day, you will be like her."
"I am already a caring person!"
"You will be a great mother like her!" He pulled her into a sweet kiss. "Let's go, Bren! We have another mother who needs appreciation!"
"Yeah! Thanks, baby!" She clinged onto his left arm and they both moved into the kitchen.