LightReader

Chapter 3 - Cracks Beneath the Surface

The morning sun painted the endless sea in shades of gold, but its warmth couldn't chase away the chill that had settled over the Blue Horizon cruise liner. What had begun as a journey of dreams and celebrations had turned into something far darker. Samar Malhotra's lifeless body, discovered near the humming engine room in the early hours, had transformed the floating paradise into a prison of whispers and suspicious glances.

 

The news had spread like wildfire through the ship's corridors. Passengers who had danced together the night before now avoided eye contact. The laughter that had echoed through the halls was replaced by hushed conversations and fearful murmurs.

 

Captain Sharma had done what protocol demanded: sealed the decks, informed the ship's management. But they were still days away from the nearest port. The Blue Horizon continued its journey through the Arabian Sea, carrying its passengers and a deadly secret that would have to be unraveled at sea.

 

It was then that Inspector Ravi Deshmukh stepped forward. Even on vacation, his instincts remained sharp. The captain, desperate for answers, had granted him temporary authority to investigate.

 

Deshmukh stood in the main lounge, his experienced eyes scanning the gathered passengers. At fifty-two, with graying temples and a calm demeanor that commanded respect, he had seen enough of human nature to know that everyone was capable of darkness under the right circumstances.

 

He had chosen the Sunset Lounge for his interviews-a space usually filled with music and laughter, now eerily quiet. The morning light filtered through large windows, casting long shadows across the plush furniture. It felt like the perfect setting for truths to emerge.

 

Kunal Malhotra sat hunched in the velvet armchair, looking far older than his twenty years. His clothes from the previous evening were wrinkled, his eyes

red-rimmed with exhaustion and grief. When he finally spoke, his voice cracked like glass.

"Sir, I argued with Papa last night."

 

Deshmukh leaned forward slightly. "Tell me about it, beta."

 

Kunal's hands trembled as he spoke. "He wanted me to quit photography. Said it was just a hobby for spoiled kids. he said, 'You're my only son. You have responsibilities.' He wanted me to take over his business, become an engineer like him."

 

The young man's voice grew bitter. "I told him I'd rather die than live his life. I

I said... I said I hated him for not understanding me." "When did this happen?"

"Just before the welcome party. Right there in the corridor outside our cabin. People were staring." Kunal wiped his eyes with the back of his hand. "The last thing I said to my father was that I hated him. How do I live with that, Sir?"

 

Deshmukh's voice softened. "Where did you go after the argument?"

 

"To the top deck, where everyone was-I got to talk with Nisha and Tanya after that. They were trying to cheer me up. We stayed there for hours, talking about everything except Papa."

 

"And you didn't go near the engine room?"

 

"Never. I didn't want to see Papa again that night. I was too angry, too hurt." Kunal looked up with desperate eyes. "But Sir, I would never... he was my father. Even when I hated what he said, I still loved him."

 

Deshmukh nodded, making careful notes. The boy's pain seemed genuine, but he had learned long ago that grief and guilt could look remarkably similar.

 

In the girls' shared suite, Riya sat cross-legged on her bed, mechanically scrolling through her phone. Nisha was brushing her hair by the mirror while Tanya organized her scattered jewelry. The normalcy of their actions felt forced, like actors playing roles they no longer believed in.

 

"Yaar, this Wi-Fi is so weird," Riya said, frowning at her screen. "It's showing notifications from yesterday that I never saw."

 

Nisha paused mid-brush. "What kind of notifications?"

 

"Messages, photos syncing... some with timestamps that don't make sense." Riya's thumb hovered over a particular notification. It showed a message sent at 11:47 PM-when she was sure Nisha had been with them on the deck.

 

"Must be some server glitch," Tanya said quickly, too quickly.

 

But Riya had always been the observant one in their group. She noticed how Nisha's hand had tightened on the brush, how Tanya had suddenly become very interested in arranging her earrings. These were her best friends-girls she had shared secrets with since college. But something had changed.

 

Later, as they got ready for breakfast, Riya watched them in the mirror.

Nisha seemed jumpy, constantly checking her phone. Tanya kept making forced conversation about anything except the previous night. The easy friendship that had brought them on this trip felt strained, like a favorite sweater that no longer fit quite right.

 

"Did you guys sleep well?" Riya asked casually.

 

"Like a baby," Tanya replied, but her smile didn't reach her eyes. Nisha just nodded, avoiding eye contact.

Riya felt a chill that had nothing to do with the air conditioning. These were her dearest friends, but suddenly she felt like she was sharing a room with strangers.

 

When Kabir and Ananya entered the lounge, they looked like the perfect newlywed couple. he is tall and protective, she delicate and devoted. But Deshmukh's trained eye caught the subtle signs: the way Kabir's jaw was clenched, how Ananya's smile seemed painted on.

 

"Did either of you interact with Mr. Malhotra last night?" Deshmukh asked, settling back in his chair.

 

"No, Inspector," Kabir answered immediately. "We saw him at the welcome party, but we didn't speak."

 

Ananya nodded in agreement, but Deshmukh noticed how her fingers twisted her wedding ring-a nervous habit he'd seen countless times before.

 

"Interesting. From what I understand, Mr. Malhotra was quite the socializer. He seemed to know everyone on this ship."

 

"Well, we're on our honeymoon," Kabir said stiffly. "We were more focused on each other than on meeting new people."

 

"Of course," Deshmukh murmured. "And your cabin-it's near the stairs leading to the engine room, isn't it?"

 

Ananya's breath caught slightly. "We... yes, but we didn't go down there. Why would we?"

 

"Just curious. Sometimes people take wrong turns on these big ships, especially after a few drinks."

 

Kabir's face reddened. "Inspector, if you're suggesting something, please be direct."

Deshmukh raised his hands peacefully. "Just routine questions, Mr. Kabir. Please, enjoy your honeymoon."

 

As they left, Ananya stumbled slightly. Kabir caught her arm, but not before Deshmukh noticed how she flinched at his touch.

 

He made a note: Tension beneath the surface. Fear-but of what?

 

Meera and Aryan entered next, and the contrast was stark. Where Kabir and Ananya had performed unity, these two carried their distance like visible wounds. They sat separately, avoided eye contact, and spoke to Deshmukh as if they were strangers forced to share the same space.

 

"How did you know the deceased?" Deshmukh asked.

 

"We met him briefly at dinner," Aryan replied. "Just small talk about business, the ship, nothing significant."

 

"And where were you both last night during the party?"

 

Meera spoke up for the first time. "Together, mostly. It was... it was supposed to be our attempt at fixing things."

 

"Fixing things?"

 

Aryan's voice was hollow. "We're getting divorced, Inspector. This trip was supposed to be our last attempt at saving fifteen years of marriage."

 

Deshmukh studied them both. Here was a different kind of pain-not the sharp agony of sudden loss, but the slow, grinding hurt of love dying by degrees.

 

"Did you notice anything unusual last night?"

 

They exchanged a glance-the first real connection Deshmukh had seen between them.

 

"There was a moment," Meera said slowly, "when Mr. Malhotra was talking to some young people. He seemed upset about something. But we were... we were dealing with our own issues."

 

"The young people-were they his son and friends?" "I think so. The boy looked very angry."

Aryan added quietly, "Families can be complicated, Inspector.

Sometimes the people we love most are the ones we hurt the deepest."

 

Something in his voice made Deshmukh look at him more carefully. "Indeed, Mr. Aryan. Indeed."

 

Later, in the ship's café, old Mr. Gokhale sat with his evening tea, watching the world with the patience that comes with age. When he saw Aryan sitting alone at a nearby table, staring at his untouched coffee, he gestured the younger man over.

 

"Beta, come sit with me. Grief shared is grief halved, they say."

 

Aryan joined him reluctantly. There was something about Mr. Gokhale's weathered face that reminded him of his own father the same kind eyes, the same gentle authority.

 

"You know, I've been married to my Kamala for forty years," the old man began, stirring his tea slowly. "People ask me the secret, as if love is a recipe you can follow."

 

"What do you tell them, uncle?"

 

Mr. Gokhale smiled. "I tell them there is no secret. Only choice. Every morning, I wake up and choose her again. Some days it's easy, some days it's the hardest thing I've ever done."

 

Aryan felt his throat tighten. "What if... what if you've made so many mistakes that choosing doesn't matter anymore?"

 

"Beta, let me tell you something." The old man leaned forward, his voice gentle but firm. "I've seen couples who fight like cats and dogs but would die for each other. I've seen couples who never raise their voices but sleep like strangers in the same bed. The fights don't kill love-silence does."

 

"But what if the silence has been there too long?"

 

"Then you break it. You speak. You say the words that terrify you most." Mr. Gokhale's eyes grew distant. "I watched that poor Mr. Malhotra last night at the party. I saw how he looked at his son-so much love, so much pride, but the words were stuck in his throat. Now he'll never get the chance to say them."

 

Aryan's hands trembled around his coffee cup. "I don't even know if she wants to hear my words anymore."

 

"Beta, I saw how you looked when that young man was talking to your wife last night. That wasn't indifference-that was a man afraid of losing what he loves most. Jealousy, you see, is just love wearing armor."

"Maybe it's too late for us, uncle."

 

Mr. Gokhale reached across and patted Aryan's hand. "As long as the heart is beating, it's never too late. Death-now that's too late. That poor man downstairs, he'll never get another chance to tell his son he understood his dreams, that he was proud of his passion for photography."

 

Tears slipped down Aryan's cheeks. "How do you start again after seven years of slow endings?"

 

"The same way you started the first time, beta. With honesty. With hope. And with the courage to be hurt again."

 

As evening approached, the ship felt different. The festive decorations from the welcome party looked garish in the fading light. Passengers moved in small, nervous groups, everyone suspicious of everyone else.

 

Nisha sat alone on the deck, watching the endless water. Her phone buzzed with messages, but she ignored them. She could feel Riya's eyes on her whenever they were in the same room, could sense her friend's growing suspicion. The weight of secrets felt heavier than the sea itself.

 

When Tanya approached, their conversation was stilted, full of unfinished sentences and meaningful looks.

 

"Nisha, you need to tell Riya soon," Tanya whispered urgently, glancing around to make sure they were alone.

 

"I can't. You know how she is-she'll never forgive me."

 

"But if she finds out on her own, it'll be much worse. She's already suspicious. I can see it in her eyes."

 

Nisha's voice trembled. "What if she hates me? What if she thinks I-"

 

"That's exactly why you need to tell her yourself. As her friend." Tanya's grip tightened on the railing. "The longer you wait, the worse it gets."

 

"I know, I know..." Nisha closed her eyes, feeling the weight pressing down on her chest. "But Tanya, once I tell her, there's no going back. She'll never look at me the same way."

 

"She deserves to know the truth," Tanya said softly. "You said it yourself-she's your best friend."

Unbeknownst to them, Inspector Deshmukh had stepped out onto the adjacent deck for some fresh air. The sound of their urgent whispers carried on the evening breeze, and while he couldn't make out every word, the tone was unmistakable

able-guilt, fear, desperation.

 

He paused, listening carefully. "...tell her yourself..." "...she'll never forgive..." "...deserves to know the truth..."

 

Interesting. The inspector made a mental note but didn't approach. Sometimes the best information came from letting people think they weren't being watched. For now, he would observe and wait.

 

Back in his temporary office, a converted conference room, Inspector Deshmukh spread out his notes. Names, times, relationships, motives-they formed a web of connections that grew more complex with each interview.

 

Kunal Malhotra: Angry son with a public argument just hours before his father's death.

 

Kabir and Ananya: Newlyweds with secrets, located suspiciously close to the crime scene.

 

The friend group: Young women with something to hide, their unity cracking under pressure.

 

Meera and Aryan: A dying marriage, jealousy, and proximity to the victim. Each had an opportunity. Each had secrets. But which secrets were deadly?

He rubbed his temples. In his experience, murder rarely happened in isolation. It was usually the final act in a drama that had been building for weeks, months, sometimes years. The cruise ship was just the stage where all these separate stories had finally collided.

 

Outside his window, the sea stretched endlessly in all directions. Somewhere on this floating world of luxury and dreams, a killer walked among them, carrying their terrible secret.

 

Deshmukh picked up his pen and began writing his preliminary notes. Tomorrow, he would continue his investigation-he still needed to speak with the friends more thoroughly, and he wanted to talk to Mr. and Mrs. Gokhale, who seemed to observe everyone with the wisdom of age. There were more layers to uncover, more secrets to unravel.

 

The Blue Horizon continued its journey through the darkness, carrying its passengers toward an uncertain dawn.

...

Chapter 3 is here! 🕵️‍♂️Things are getting intense—secrets, lies, and a whole lot of side-eye 👀So… who do you think did it? Kunal? The honeymooners? The not-so-happy friends? Or someone unexpected?

And what do you think about the characters so far? Who's your favorite? Who's acting a little too suspicious?

Tell me your theories—I'm loving the guesses! 😄

More Chapters